I started writing this as a reply to this thread on askMRP, but thought it would be worth posting here. The question posed was, essentially, if arguments ever stop and, implicitly, how to handle them.
My job right now is to argue (attorney). It's rare to have a case where I'm not arguing against someone. There's almost always an attorney or party on the other end. But if I were to run for judge and win, my new job would be to hear someone else's arguments and make a decision. Which role are you playing in your marriage?
Playing Attorney
When you DEER and argue with your wife, you are putting yourself on an equal playing field with her. You're saying that you're one attorney and she's the other and you're both pushing for differing agendas. The problem is that there's no invisible judge presiding over the situation. This means that you're both implicitly assuming that there's some objective "right answer" and you're more closely aligned with that objective reality. But because that objective reality is an inanimate ideology that never acts or reveals itself, the argument itself becomes the centerpiece of the show. The argument is emotionally devastating in many such cases because there is no absolute resolution - only a concession toward trial and error based on whoever has more steel plates in their head to keep banging.
- EXAMPLE: Suppose she starts arguing that you should never spank your kids. You argue back that spanking is perfectly appropriate and beneficial. There's so much evidence on both ends of the spectrum that nobody can definitively say whose way is better. There is no magical parenting fairy who will appear to screaming parents and tell them who's right.
Whenever you engage in an argument in a back-and-forth manner, even though you're arguing against her, you're actually validating her view. By playing the role of "opposing counsel" you're communicating that objective truth has not been discovered on that issue yet. You cannot then play the, "I'm the guy, I'm the leader, so I win" card because now it comes from a place of weakness. You have not persuaded her that your way is better, and you have just proven to her that no objective reality is going to decide the case either ... so, in her mind she's following a guy who keeps getting it wrong.
- NOTE: Winning arguments and getting your way aren't methods of strengthening your frame or "holding frame." Being an argumentative jerk who never backs down might be a persona you want to craft into your frame, but it is not your frame itself. Your frame is who you are and how you project that to those around you. If you deviate from who you want to be just to win an argument or get your way, you may prove a point, but you've broken frame to do it. You've shown her that she has the power (through sacrifice of her ideologies) to change you, for better or worse. This is not a display of strength, but of weakness.
Playing Judge
Instead, you just need to take the position of judge from the get-go. At that point, you're not arguing with her - you're listening to her argument. That's a huge difference.
Interestingly, go watch a real trial (not Judge Judy crap) and you'll notice something right away: Judges STFU. They sit there and listen. They don't argue. They really only speak when someone objects. When a witness is finished or the case concludes, the judge might ask some questions, but they never engage in the argument itself. They never argue back. They are only seeking more information with which to make a wise and informed decision. The judge's opinion, then, becomes objective reality. Yes, it may be subjective as to the decision itself, but the authority from which the decision is made is objective - something that everyone knows not to defy. As attorneys often tell clients, "I don't care if it's a bad decision; you better do what the judge says anyway."
Now, in his opinion the judge does address the arguments. He explains to the attorneys and parties, "I heard what you had to say and here's what I think about that." He explains himself because this builds validity and respect behind the ruling. Attorneys and parties learn from this which judges are the "good ones" and which are the "bad ones" - and it's how you preempt comfort tests, by letting her know that you heard, understood, and valued her input, even if you end up chucking it out the window. If the judge did not do this, every case would be appealed. But even if a party disagrees with the ruling, if the opinion is well-reasoned the party knows that the ruling will stand, even despite appeal. The difference is that the judge is not arguing, he's explaining. He's establishing precedent and saying, "If something similar happens again in the future, this is how I'm going to process that situation and rule on it."
Whether you're an attorney or judge, the arguments will be never-ending. The difference is that as an attorney the arguments are against you; but when you're a judge, the arguments are to you. Position yourself as judge, not attorney. Don't argue back; rather, STFU until she's said all she has to say, then issue your ruling: "Here's what I'm doing and here's why I'm doing it. I heard what you had to say, and here are my thoughts on it." If she tries to argue back, let her know that you're not arguing - you're deciding. I've had good luck often reminding my wife, "We could argue about this, but then there would never be finality. Do you want to have a decision and move forward or do you want to debate for the next three hours?" The question is, of course, rhetorical - she knows I'm not going to entertain the debate even if she says that's what she wants.
[–]SorcererKingMRP SAGE - MRP MODERATOR20 points21 points22 points (5 children) | Copy Link
[–]Red-Curious[S] 11 points12 points13 points (0 children) | Copy Link
[–]BobbyPeruMRP Approved4 points5 points6 points (1 child) | Copy Link
[–]LghtrThrstngGods0 points1 point2 points (0 children) | Copy Link
[–]average_dudereino0 points1 point2 points (0 children) | Copy Link
[–][deleted] 0 points1 point2 points (0 children) | Copy Link
[–]BobbyPeruMRP Approved12 points13 points14 points (5 children) | Copy Link
[–]InwardLookingMarried3 points4 points5 points (0 children) | Copy Link
[–]SteelSharpensSteelMRP MODERATOR4 points5 points6 points (3 children) | Copy Link
[–]BobbyPeruMRP Approved2 points3 points4 points (2 children) | Copy Link
[–]SteelSharpensSteelMRP MODERATOR2 points3 points4 points (1 child) | Copy Link
[–]BobbyPeruMRP Approved3 points4 points5 points (0 children) | Copy Link
[–]bogeyd6MRP MODERATOR10 points11 points12 points (17 children) | Copy Link
[–]straius 1 points1 points1 points [recovered] | Copy Link
[–]bogeyd6MRP MODERATOR3 points4 points5 points (14 children) | Copy Link
[–]SteelSharpensSteelMRP MODERATOR4 points5 points6 points (6 children) | Copy Link
[–]weakandsensitive0 points1 point2 points (5 children) | Copy Link
[–]straius1 point2 points3 points (4 children) | Copy Link
[–]weakandsensitive0 points1 point2 points (3 children) | Copy Link
[–]bogeyd6MRP MODERATOR2 points3 points4 points (2 children) | Copy Link
[–]SteelSharpensSteelMRP MODERATOR0 points1 point2 points (1 child) | Copy Link
[–]weakandsensitive0 points1 point2 points (0 children) | Copy Link
[–]straius0 points1 point2 points (6 children) | Copy Link
[–]Rian_StoneHard Core Navy Red3 points4 points5 points (5 children) | Copy Link
[–]pridebrah1 point2 points3 points (1 child) | Copy Link
[–]Rian_StoneHard Core Navy Red1 point2 points3 points (0 children) | Copy Link
[–]straius0 points1 point2 points (2 children) | Copy Link
[–]bogeyd6MRP MODERATOR3 points4 points5 points (1 child) | Copy Link
[–]straius0 points1 point2 points (0 children) | Copy Link
[–]470_2_700_nm2 points3 points4 points (0 children) | Copy Link
[–]weakandsensitive8 points9 points10 points (22 children) | Copy Link
[–]Red-Curious[S] 12 points13 points14 points (21 children) | Copy Link
[–]Rian_StoneHard Core Navy Red7 points8 points9 points (20 children) | Copy Link
[–]Red-Curious[S] 4 points5 points6 points (6 children) | Copy Link
[–]Rian_StoneHard Core Navy Red0 points1 point2 points (5 children) | Copy Link
[–]Red-Curious[S] 2 points3 points4 points (4 children) | Copy Link
[–]Rian_StoneHard Core Navy Red1 point2 points3 points (3 children) | Copy Link
[–]470_2_700_nm1 point2 points3 points (0 children) | Copy Link
[–]BluepillProfessorMarried-MRP MODERATOR0 points1 point2 points (1 child) | Copy Link
[–]Rian_StoneHard Core Navy Red0 points1 point2 points (0 children) | Copy Link
[–]gettingmymojobackMRP APPROVED0 points1 point2 points (12 children) | Copy Link
[–]Rian_StoneHard Core Navy Red6 points7 points8 points (2 children) | Copy Link
[–]RawgerOThornhill2 points3 points4 points (0 children) | Copy Link
[–]gettingmymojobackMRP APPROVED0 points1 point2 points (0 children) | Copy Link
[–]Red-Curious[S] 4 points5 points6 points (8 children) | Copy Link
[–]BluepillProfessorMarried-MRP MODERATOR1 point2 points3 points (1 child) | Copy Link
[–]Red-Curious[S] -1 points0 points1 point (0 children) | Copy Link
[–]RawgerOThornhill2 points3 points4 points (5 children) | Copy Link
[–]Red-Curious[S] 3 points4 points5 points (1 child) | Copy Link
[–]redpillrobby0 points1 point2 points (0 children) | Copy Link
[–]HobbesTheBrave0 points1 point2 points (1 child) | Copy Link
[–]BluepillProfessorMarried-MRP MODERATOR0 points1 point2 points (0 children) | Copy Link
[–]theoppositeopinion18 points9 points10 points (0 children) | Copy Link
[–]SteelSharpensSteelMRP MODERATOR6 points7 points8 points (2 children) | Copy Link
[–]bogeyd6 1 points1 points1 points [recovered] | Copy Link
[–][deleted] 6 points7 points8 points (7 children) | Copy Link
[–]PersaeusMRP APPROVED4 points5 points6 points (0 children) | Copy Link
[–]RuleZeroDADMRP APPROVED2 points3 points4 points (1 child) | Copy Link
[–][deleted] 3 points4 points5 points (0 children) | Copy Link
[–]PersaeusMRP APPROVED0 points1 point2 points (3 children) | Copy Link
[–][deleted] 0 points1 point2 points (2 children) | Copy Link
[–]Rian_StoneHard Core Navy Red0 points1 point2 points (1 child) | Copy Link
[–][deleted] 0 points1 point2 points (0 children) | Copy Link
[–]BluepillProfessorMarried-MRP MODERATOR5 points6 points7 points (0 children) | Copy Link
[–]drty_prMRP APPROVED3 points4 points5 points (3 children) | Copy Link
[–]JDRoedellMRP APPROVED0 points1 point2 points (2 children) | Copy Link
[–]RPWolfUnplugging2 points3 points4 points (1 child) | Copy Link
[–]JDRoedellMRP APPROVED0 points1 point2 points (0 children) | Copy Link
[–]JDRoedellMRP APPROVED4 points5 points6 points (1 child) | Copy Link
[–]redsprinklersystem2 points3 points4 points (0 children) | Copy Link
[–][deleted] 2 points3 points4 points (0 children) | Copy Link
[–]IhaveZerotolerance2 points3 points4 points (0 children) | Copy Link
[–]wildnight98Well on his way1 point2 points3 points (0 children) | Copy Link
[–]Flagfootball991 point2 points3 points (4 children) | Copy Link
[–]AexNBacon0 points1 point2 points (3 children) | Copy Link
[–]Flagfootball990 points1 point2 points (2 children) | Copy Link
[–]AexNBacon0 points1 point2 points (1 child) | Copy Link
[–]Flagfootball991 point2 points3 points (0 children) | Copy Link
[–][deleted] 1 point2 points3 points (0 children) | Copy Link
[–][deleted] 1 point2 points3 points (0 children) | Copy Link
[–][deleted] 1 point2 points3 points (0 children) | Copy Link
[–]redpillrobby1 point2 points3 points (26 children) | Copy Link
[–]bogeyd6MRP MODERATOR2 points3 points4 points (0 children) | Copy Link
[–]straius1 point2 points3 points (5 children) | Copy Link
[–]redpillrobby2 points3 points4 points (4 children) | Copy Link
[–]straius 1 points1 points1 points [recovered] | Copy Link
[–]bogeyd6MRP MODERATOR1 point2 points3 points (1 child) | Copy Link
[–]straius0 points1 point2 points (0 children) | Copy Link
[–]redpillrobby0 points1 point2 points (0 children) | Copy Link
[–]Red-Curious[S] 1 point2 points3 points (18 children) | Copy Link
[–]Rian_StoneHard Core Navy Red2 points3 points4 points (6 children) | Copy Link
[–]Red-Curious[S] 1 point2 points3 points (5 children) | Copy Link
[–]Rian_StoneHard Core Navy Red0 points1 point2 points (2 children) | Copy Link
[–]Red-Curious[S] 0 points1 point2 points (1 child) | Copy Link
[–]Rian_StoneHard Core Navy Red0 points1 point2 points (0 children) | Copy Link
[–]PersaeusMRP APPROVED0 points1 point2 points (1 child) | Copy Link
[–]Red-Curious[S] 0 points1 point2 points (0 children) | Copy Link
[–]bogeyd6MRP MODERATOR1 point2 points3 points (9 children) | Copy Link
[–]Red-Curious[S] 1 point2 points3 points (8 children) | Copy Link
[–]UEMcGillMarried- MRP MODERATOR1 point2 points3 points (6 children) | Copy Link
[–]PersaeusMRP APPROVED1 point2 points3 points (2 children) | Copy Link
[–]RuleZeroDADMRP APPROVED0 points1 point2 points (1 child) | Copy Link
[–]pridebrah0 points1 point2 points (0 children) | Copy Link
[–]Red-Curious[S] 0 points1 point2 points (2 children) | Copy Link
[–]UEMcGillMarried- MRP MODERATOR0 points1 point2 points (1 child) | Copy Link
[–]Red-Curious[S] 0 points1 point2 points (0 children) | Copy Link
[–]redpillrobby0 points1 point2 points (0 children) | Copy Link
[–]redpillrobby1 point2 points3 points (0 children) | Copy Link
[–]wekacuck0 points1 point2 points (9 children) | Copy Link
[–]Red-Curious[S] 1 point2 points3 points (8 children) | Copy Link
[–]BostonBrakeJobRoTY1 point2 points3 points (0 children) | Copy Link
[–]wekacuck0 points1 point2 points (6 children) | Copy Link
[–]BostonBrakeJobRoTY0 points1 point2 points (4 children) | Copy Link
[–]wekacuck0 points1 point2 points (3 children) | Copy Link
[–]BostonBrakeJobRoTY0 points1 point2 points (2 children) | Copy Link
[–]wekacuck0 points1 point2 points (1 child) | Copy Link
[–]BostonBrakeJobRoTY0 points1 point2 points (0 children) | Copy Link
[–]Red-Curious[S] 0 points1 point2 points (0 children) | Copy Link
[–][deleted] 0 points1 point2 points (0 children) | Copy Link
[–]boodie19610 points1 point2 points (1 child) | Copy Link
[–]Red-Curious[S] 0 points1 point2 points (0 children) | Copy Link