Long story short: I (22F) had a relationship with a married man, let's call him "Peter" (39m) when I had just turned 19. I met "Peter" at a friend's work football game. When I saw "Peter" I was instantly attracted to him, he was older (36), nice smile, Hazel eyes, athletic build. He introduced himself to me as he said hello to my friend and his fellow coworkers, as the night progressed we all decided we would go grab a bite at a near sports grill. As I was walking towards the car with my friend I heard someone mention my "black leggings" ( I am 5'3, 120lbs, hazel eyes, pretty good shape - flat stomach, average sized breasts and plump butt, hit the gym 4x week, all around I consider myself a pretty girl) as I turn around he's behind me and smiling.

We make it to the sports grill and most of the group sits in a table, and my friend and a smaller groups sit at the table next to it.. "Peter" chooses the chair across from me. I notice he has a ring. As my friends and I begin to talk about college and careers choices, he asks me what I do for work, I politely reply " I work as a receptionist and handle small accounts for an accounting firm" to which he asks me what if that's what I plan on studying. As the time goes by we begin talking about boating (we're down in Miami) and fishing, he asks me if I enjoy the water and I tell him "I'm too chicken shit" he smiles and tells me "maybe what you need is a man to throw you off and pick you back up" I smile and lower my head - this man is flirting with me.. BUT he's got a ring on THE finger. I step out to the bathroom and when I come back everyone's paying their bills, I don't get mine so I ask the waitress so my bill and she tells me "he paid your tab", when I turn to him he's smiling and I tell him "thank you that wasn't necessary". I get up from my table and start making my way out of the restaurant and into my car, we lock eyes, smile and I go home.

I was intrigued by this man but as the weekend passed by I thought nothing of it, after a week passes I get a text message from a number I don't recognize and when I open it, it reads " Hi, its's Peter we ate at sports grill in a group, remember me?"... the rest is history ( 2 years to be exact), basically told me his marriage was broken and irreparable, they were talking about divorce and the whole nine yards. As our affair progressed I started becoming impatient, he wasn't separating from her, still living with her and still meeting in secret.. NOT getting divorced. Finally after 7 months I tell him I need more, he tells me wants more too, he thinks about marriage and kids with me, he loves me but he's got a daughter and he's got to take it slow. He tells me to wait, he's got a plan, I give in. 5 months go by and still nothing is happening, I'm growing angry, crazy, depressed. Now we are fighting, and he's telling me he's got to do right by his daughter, I seek psychological help and I'm diagnosed with depression and anxiety. (I know what you're all thinking - I got what I deserve for being a whore). By this time I'm in too deep, and even though I know now he doesn't love me, he isn't going to leave his wife, and he's buying a home with her... I stay for another year, why? because I have hope if i'm around he might just leave... he didn't. Finally after losing 20lbs, having major anxiety and depression, I build some strength and I walk away.

2 month after I meet "John" (31M), I'm focusing on me and my health going to the gym and trying to gain some weight. I'm on Facebook one day and I come across this picture of a guy, smirking, dark brown eyes, chiseled jaw, athletic build, sexy. I add him on facebook, nothing happens for 3-4 days he likes a picture of mine and that's all, I build up the courage and message him.. simple "Hi there", he says "hi, how are you?" and I reply " I'm good, hows your day going?" and he drops a huge bomb " Hey, how do you know "PETER"?" I go to out friends and realize he's a mutual friend. I obviously don't want to disclose any personal information so I just say he's an old friend. "john" and I decide to stop talking. A few hours pass by and I still thinking about "John" and I remember "Peter" would mention him from time to time and how he'd say how alike we were. I message him again and fast forward we are living together, but it's not all flower fields. Because of my relationship with "John", "Peter" doesn't want to have a friendship with "John" and he's hurting and missing his friend (they were friends for 12 years), Because of my relationship with "peter", "John" is angry at me and disappointed in my poor choice, sexually frustrated because he can't reach climax due to previous explicit conversations with "peter" about me.

7 months into my relationship with "John" we are still having problems in bed and they are causing fights, around this time I find out "John" cheated on me a few months earlier. I pack my stuff and I'm ready to leave the house but he convinces me to give him another chance, that he's never done it again, it was a mistake he would never repeat. I give in.

2 months pass and we are still having discussions about my past with "peter", " how could I let myself into an affair, where were my morals, my self respect", " I must have really enjoyed it and loved him since I continued to spread my legs for a man who gave no commitment and was clearly using me for 2 years". After weeks and weeks of this and fighting "john" breaks up with me and I move out. He moves into a different apartment, asks me for space and I just can't fathom losing him, so I cry and try to talk him out of breaking up.

It's been 4 months and "John" and I are still not together, we talk almost everyday, fight at least once a week and have sex once or twice a month. I want to break this cycle. He says he want's to take it slow and casual, with no expectations. he says he doesn't know how to move on from the insecurity m affair has left on him and how to not feel embarrassed about being with a woman who had an affair with his friend. I don't want casual, I want commitment. As I've read through the RED PILL "Women own sex and men own commitment" I am not willing to give up what I own without the same in return.

I am 22 now but I crave marriage and family, I don't want to date to pass time, I want to enjoy my time with a captain, someone I can enjoy my days with, go on trips, go fishing, who I can rely on for protection and emotional support, to which in some time may result in marriage and a family. I want all those things with "John", he's a leader, he's sexy, he's great in bed and we are extremely compatible (Like the same things), but he's set on taking things "SLOW and CASUAL", I have no problem taking things slow but I need commitment, when I tell him this he says I'm intense.

I guess what I am asking here is what should I do?

- Should I stand my ground and demand what I feel I deserve? Unconditioanl Love and Commitment?

or

- Should I give in to his want and agree to take things " slow and casual " ?

TL; DR

- I had an affair with a man for 2 years

- turns out he's the bestfriend of my BF now

- my bf lost that friendship due to dating me and resents me for it, misses his friends

- my bf and I have issues in bed because of it

- my bf wants to take things slow and casual but I want commitment