It seems that on Reddit every single person knows a man that is by all accounts below average, but somehow still is extremely successful with attractive women, through sheer force of his personality, charisma, or whatever fantastical reason people come up with, but in my personal life I've hardly ever seen it.

The closest I've seen to this phenomena happening in real life is guys that have a negative trait that is balanced out by a positive trait (classic example would be short, but very handsome face).

But personally I've never seen a George Costanza guy that was below average across the board (speaking in terms of sexual dimorphism), but somehow still pulled hot babes through his personal magnetism or something.
Let me also say, I'm specifically talking about pulling hot chicks which is what these people always seem to claim what is going on -I wont deny that a below average man can get into a relationship with some ugly fat woman, but that's a far cry from banging supermodels all the time.

So what's going on here?
Do people like this actually exist? Am I the fool here, for not ever having encountered somebody like this? Is Danny Devito-maxxing legit? Do you know a 5'2 Indian janitor that is banging hot babes all the time? Can you charm swedish supermodels into your bed using animal magnetism while looking like quasimodo?