Feminism 2017

1) read your sources "When women considered him for a long-term relationship, owning the sports car held no advantage relative to owning an economy car". Also dont supply a source behind a pay wall, what are you trying to achieve. Furthermore you missed the point, I dont not care If the generalization is true or not, I was criticizing you for not clearly expressing that it was just a generalization

2) You completely misinterpreted my point, I am criticizing "It becomes a catch 22..." for comparing "it's consequences" (it's being abolishing the wage gap) and the wage gap existing. your example is irrelevant to these two experiences being compared and therefore a red herring

3) Another red herring, I am not arguing about whether or not there would be complaining but whether or not there is an inherent contradiction in the position presented in the meme; "Could you explain the contradiction for me?"

4) Again if its not clear I am arguing that there is not contradiction, which youre rebuttal makes no argument against.

5) It's not a problem, there is nothing inherently immoral in someone not getting what they want if there is no reason that they ought to have it.

response to edit 2: "is speculation" Irrelevant if position A and B are inherently contradictory than any speculated person who holds A and B experiences a contradiction, so identify the contradiction if your premise is true.

"the pay gap indicating systematic oppression because of itself implies circular logic. " Youre really going to have to elaborate here as I have no Idea what you are saying, maybe ill restate the opinion of the speculated person. It should be noted the the validity of their opinions is actually irrelevant to whether or not there is a contradiction. If women are equal, but there is an unequal outcome present (wage gap) then it follows that there is some factor which is causes the unequal outcome (therefore oppressing the outcome of equality). since they are part of a society this is societal or institutional(which can be defined as "an organization, establishment, foundation, society...") oppression. You might be interested to know that I believe equality through favoring women over men is discrimination towards men and does not solve the problem of WHAT causes women to be payed less but merely THAT they are payed less (which is a morally repugnant approach)