I've been told that AWALT is a heuristic, and a sensible precaution, like gun safety.

That it's simply about keeping risks in mind, and part of male sexual strategy is minimizing the damage any one woman can do.

Okay, fine.

Why then, does the redpill endorse surprise edgeplay, with complete strangers?

Don't bother to quote the odds. It takes just one bad experience to create a sexual assault. And don't bother to claim talking about it in advance, would ruin the mood.

I've yet to meet anyone who wasn't at least a little turned on by sharing their fantasies, and how far you can push their limits, with someone they're attracted to.

If you must keep your precious amused mastery, just phrase it in the form of a challenge, and tease the information out of her. "What if I ____?" Then give her a safe word just in case she can't handle your best werewolf impersonation.

This isn't rocket science. If blue and purple can do this, and still get laid, you have no fucking excuse.

Stop behaving like children.

This is why some people are legitimately scared of the redpill. Because other people have used the 'Sex God' method, hoping to blow some minds - and then they left their partner to pick up the pieces.

Edit: If you want to change my mind, convince me that it's the only way you can get laid, or that the risk of your kink is totally worth it to the rest of the world.

Don't just complain that the way I've phrased my opinion isn't very nice. This is the same subreddit that can't stop using the words "Slut" and "Damaged goods".