ExtremeFirefighter59 Archive

Upvotes	Title	Category	Author	Subreddit	Date (UTC)
212	Majority of sexual abuse claims fraudulent	False Accusation	ExtremeFirefighter59	/r/MensRights	13/02/25 06:49 AM

Upvotes	Comment on	Subreddit	Date (UTC)
13	UK: Farmer, 20, spent THREE years on bail falsely accused of rape over drunk sex video - before case was dropped when judge saw clip and said woman 'clearly consented' Why isn’t this woman being charged with making false allegations of rape given the video clearly shows she gave consent? The man was punished correctly for making the video and showing it; now it should be the woman’s turn. There needs to be consequences for false allegations.	/r/MensRights	05/06/26 09:50 PM
5	UK: Husband 'who drove wife to suicide' is 'unfairly accused' because case against him is based on 'agenda' that women who say they've been abused 'must be telling the truth', court hears I’m struggling with how “beyond reasonable doubt” can be shown in this case.	/r/MensRights	09/04/26 02:03 AM
17	The University of Toronto is hiring a biology professor. Selection will be limited to candidates who identify as women, trans, nonbinary, Two-Spirit, and gender fluid, racialized persons/visible minorities, Indigenous Peoples, persons with disabilities. The salary range is $138,000 to $153,000. Oh I know; was just highlighting how stupid the criteria are. Even a straight white male could identify as non-binary for the job.	/r/MensRights	28/02/26 08:53 PM
22	The University of Toronto is hiring a biology professor. Selection will be limited to candidates who identify as women, trans, nonbinary, Two-Spirit, and gender fluid, racialized persons/visible minorities, Indigenous Peoples, persons with disabilities. The salary range is $138,000 to $153,000. But the white gay men can just identify as non-binary. That’s how this shit works.	/r/MensRights	28/02/26 08:18 PM
12	UK: Mother of five who falsely accused good Samaritan of rape after he gave her a lift home when he found her drunk and crying in the street is jailed. OP: Do not help at all. The weird thing about rape cases that is different to other alleged crimes is that often the only evidence is the word of the alleged victim against the alleged perpetrator. So you have one person effectively saying “I am a victim of rape” and another saying “I am a victim of false accusations”. Yet the police will frequently prosecute alleged rapes on this basis but will never prosecute the false accusations without other substantive evidence. So a two tier justice system. The UK requires “beyo…	/r/MensRights	05/02/26 08:55 PM
13	UK: Chinese student jailed for 6 years and warned she faces deportation over false rape claims against serving police officer. I doubt she will get much support from feminists because when cases like this are proven, it seriously challenges the narrative of “believe all women”. I agree with you that it was scary what might have been. Without the phone recording, he would have almost certainly been charged and gone to trial. It’s crazy that someone can be convicted on just the word of another person without a single piece of corroborating evidence. How can that possibly be “guilty beyond reasonable doubt?” The biggest na…	/r/MensRights	18/01/26 09:20 PM
71	My innocent bro, 17, was accused of rape… he hanged himself after charges were dropped – but our misery didn’t end there (The Sun) Plenty of evidence that they are not that rare. “We found that the recent consensus among sexual violence academics and women’s safety advocates that evidence shows that almost all sexual assault allegations are true, and that false allegations are extremely rare, is itself false. There is no robust way to determine the prevalence rate of false sexual assault allegations.” https://www.alrc.gov.au/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/158.-J-Papadimitriou-and-T-Nankivell.pdf	/r/MensRights	12/10/25 01:37 AM
11	UK: Woman who had one-night-stand with man she met in nightclub is ordered by High Court to pay him £25,000 after campaign of harassment, including lying to police that he had raped her The difficulty is determining the truth	/r/MensRights	11/07/25 01:16 PM
2	Where to seek support? Time to hit the gym and lift heavy.	/r/MensRights	11/05/25 11:13 AM
3	False accusations destroy lives — and the accusers rarely face consequences. The research tends to use only those cases where the police prosecute for false allegations which are obviously very hard to prove. Many people are found not guilty in court but the police do not prosecute their accusers as the system is biased. A recent sexual assault compensation scheme introduced in Australia had a majority of claimants were likely false accusations according to the police. https://www.smh.com.au/national/nsw/seven-arrested-over-1b-fake-sex-abuse-scam-in-sydney-20250213-p5lbr…	/r/MensRights	10/05/25 09:05 AM
65	UK: Britain's Got Talent finalist Andrew Johnston is cleared of raping two women This is he said she said. If he now reports them to police for fake allegations, will they be prosecuted? Of course not even though the evidence is the same word vs word.	/r/MensRights	08/05/25 10:31 PM
7	UK: Woman faces jail after admitting she lied to police that she had been sexually assaulted There is a high bar which is “beyond reasonable doubt.” The challenge, I believe, is that juries are too willing to believe the uncorroborated testimony of the alleged victim. I do not see how solely this evidence can be considered “beyond reasonable doubt”. Obviously, this makes rape cases hard to prosecute where the only issue is that of consent but we rightly use “beyond reasonable doubt” to try and ensure we do not send innocent people to gaol. I believe this concept has been corrupted in ra…	/r/MensRights	07/05/25 11:22 PM
3	UK: Woman faces jail after admitting she lied to police that she had been sexually assaulted In how many of those 5,651 cases was the man found not guilty? These are all possible false allegations. It is worth noting that many alleged rapes are about the issue of consent in that the parties agree that sexual activity occurred but differ as to whether the woman consented. Often the only evidence is the woman’s word as to what occurred. The police will still prosecute these cases. However, where the man is found not guilty, the police will not then prosecute the woman for false allegation…	/r/MensRights	07/05/25 11:13 PM
2	Women who out-earn men report less satisfying romantic relationships The article states the research was scenario based so the survey participants are given scenarios where the man earns more and scenarios where the woman earns more. So the conclusion that women are less satisfied when they earn more than their partner is based on the responses given by women in the scenario where they earn more rather than actual experience of women in this situation. This implies women do not like the idea of this subversion of traditional gender roles and presumably will there…	/r/MensRights	06/05/25 09:27 PM
14	Majority of sexual abuse claims fraudulent I think the issue is that, unlike most other crimes, the only evidence is often the word of one person against the word of another person. Sometimes the alleged crime is many decades old. Personally, I don’t see how the word of one person can be considered to be evidence beyond reasonable doubt given the many miscarriages of justice where a woman has misidentified their alleged rapist or simply made up the claim. The opposing view would be that this approach effectively makes rape unable to be p…	/r/MensRights	13/02/25 06:12 PM
2	Another false accusation exemplifying why such lies should be a felony punishable by at least ten years How many people can put up $1m bail? That’s bullshit when the only evidence was her word.	/r/MensRights	19/01/25 09:27 AM
85	UK: Criminal Cases Review Commission boss resigns. A man spent 17 years behind bars for a rape he did not commit. Woman in charge was negligent but does not accept responsibility. Hard to believe he was convicted in the first place. Stupid jury. “Malkinson was identified by the victim in an identity parade. Several key details did not match the description of the perpetrator: for example, she described the attacker as being three inches shorter than Malkinson, with a hairless chest, and no tattoos. Malkinson had chest hair and prominent tattoos on his forearms. She also said the attacker would have a “deep scratch” to his face, which Malkinson did not.. There was no DNA e…	/r/MensRights	15/01/25 12:16 PM
9	Unfair double standards This sentence is a joke when you consider the sentence the guy would have faced if convicted. Not to mention the impact on him personally if being falsely accused.	/r/MensRights	10/01/25 02:01 AM
17	UK: Female fantasist, 24, who lied about being raped by Asian grooming gang and drove innocent men to edge of suicide is released early from prison. OP: Jailed in 2023 for 8 years, released after 1. The article says she was due to be released at the half way point of her sentence in February so she has been released a month earlier than the half way point. She has served about 4 years because she was held on remand (i.e. in prison whilst waiting for the trial). Still four years is totally inadequate for what she put those men through.	/r/MensRights	06/01/25 10:02 AM
18	Slowthai found not guilty of raping two women at Oxford house party Interesting how they proceed with the case on the basis of two people’s word against two people’s word. Will they now prosecute the two women for making a false complaint on the same basis? If not, why not?	/r/MensRights	02/01/25 11:41 AM