~ archived since 2018 ~
~ archived since 2018 ~
| Upvotes | Title | Category | Author | Subreddit | Date (UTC) |
|---|
| Upvotes | Comment on | Subreddit | Date (UTC) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | Woman stabbed man so hard between the eyes it reached his brain - sentenced to just three years in prisonThis whole argument is a logical fallacy. You are of the notion that women get below minimum sentencing and therefore you assume any and all cases, like this article, are evidence of that. Sure you can change something by talking about it. But being unnuanced and presenting even the shittiest article as evidence of your statement is a fallacy. One that makes you overlooked cause nobody cares about someone saying the same shit to every female sentence they see. Then there is the article, it liter… | /r/MensRights | 01/10/21 08:15 AM |
| 1 | Woman stabbed man so hard between the eyes it reached his brain - sentenced to just three years in prisonMy evidence is that this article is limited with its information, therefore I say more might be at play than just her gender. You come with the preconception that all female cases are sentenced lower than those of male offenders. Which makes you biast and able to present even this article as evidence. Also if this were to be the case, wouldn’t that mean that there are no women with life sentences? Yet there are plenty. Which law is there that serves differently based gender? When sentencing some… | /r/MensRights | 01/10/21 07:27 AM |
| 0 | Woman stabbed man so hard between the eyes it reached his brain - sentenced to just three years in prisonMy point was quite clear. You said 3 years is very low for attempted murder. I say, well maybe she wasn’t sentenced for attempted murder then. You really think the judge came in to court, sat down, saw a women before him and decided “well let’s give her a lower sentence for the same crime”? You really think not every individual case is treated with the most equal care, taking previous presidents into account? You really think sentences don’t have to follow any rules and could just be altered, ba… | /r/MensRights | 30/09/21 09:23 PM |
| 1 | Woman stabbed man so hard between the eyes it reached his brain - sentenced to just three years in prisonOkay you can just say that, but where is the evidence? Where are two identical cases where the only difference is the gender of victim and accusee with the sentence being wildly different? You cannot just say that without evidence, it makes you sound incredible. Also sure both crimes may leave similar traumatizing and mental harm to the victim. Yet they are in no way the same. The justice system luckily also takes the intentions of the suspect into account, not just the consequences of their act… | /r/MensRights | 30/09/21 09:06 PM |
| -1 | Woman stabbed man so hard between the eyes it reached his brain - sentenced to just three years in prisonIt also said they were drinking inside and a row erupted. Very few sentences for something which clearly initiated this entire attack. A vital moment it seems, yet so little words spent on it. This article doesn’t tell us shit. Luckily tho there is an entire legal system created for centuries on the basis of equal and joust punishments. And there are people around who studied for years to make this shit work. Luckily they probably spent more hours than all of us reading this article on making th… | /r/MensRights | 30/09/21 08:39 PM |
| -1 | Woman stabbed man so hard between the eyes it reached his brain - sentenced to just three years in prisonWhere is the evidence? And how would that individual case be identical to this one? Again we don’t know wtf happened other than “a row erupted”. How is this case compared to rape? Rape is an intentional act of violence for personal gain, again cause we don’t know anything about the specifics; this case could very well have been an act of self defense. Again I don’t say there is no gender inequality. All I’m saying is; don’t waste time presenting every female centered case as an example of this i… | /r/MensRights | 30/09/21 08:08 PM |
| -11 | Woman stabbed man so hard between the eyes it reached his brain - sentenced to just three years in prisonBut okay just eh.... what if in this case the penalty was right 🤷♂️ like we don’t know the fuck she pulled the knife for. What if he did something first to provoke? Ofc stabbing someone in the face is not being the right or legal thing to do, for which she got punished. But why is THIS an example of gender injustice within the system? Like guys yes y’all are right things are wrong, but not every female centered case is wrong by definition. Saying such things would only water down the real argum… | /r/MensRights | 30/09/21 01:17 PM |
© TheRedArchive 2026. All rights reserved.
created by /u/dream-hunter