HandBananaHeartCarl Archive

Upvotes	Title	Category	Author	Subreddit	Date (UTC)

Upvotes	Comment on	Subreddit	Date (UTC)
16	Do you agree with Iliza Schlesinger's take on hateful undesirable saying that it's "natural selection"? Misogynistic ultraconservatives have higher birth rates than more progressive men, so by her own logic her views are being eradicated through "natural selection"	/r/PurplePillDebate	04/09/25 08:54 AM
2	Men understand the concept of aggression significantly better than women. whats baffling is that people are slightly more confident in their odds of beating an elephant than a grizzly. So there are people walking around who think "i couldnt beat a grizzly, but an elephant should be doable"	/r/PurplePillDebate	16/12/24 10:43 PM
4	There’s nothing wrong with high standards. But historically, 40% of men didn’t reproduce and there was no “incel uprising” Thats because primitive society was actually a constant form of "incel uprising", in which men were expected to go out and pillage and attack other tribes to take their property and women. Many died before they could reproduce, but those that did had plenty of women to do so with.	/r/PurplePillDebate	11/10/24 12:27 PM
1	The manosphere does not care about fixing men's issues No one said it's your job. Plenty of men will fill the void instead. It's not their job either, but they do it anyway. Of course, you cannot complain that the advice they give is too "misogynistic" or whatever when you're not doing anything yourself. You've forfeited that right.	/r/PurplePillDebate	24/07/24 08:25 PM
6	The manosphere does not care about fixing men's issues There's a shitton of money to be made in therapy, what the fuck are you talking about? The real reason is that classic therapy is just very limited in what it can do; Going to a therapist and talking for an hour aint gonna cut it.	/r/PurplePillDebate	24/07/24 08:19 PM
15	The manosphere does not care about fixing men's issues No, people refuse because Menslib is an awful subreddit that only pays lip-service to men's issues, and has glaring blind spots when it comes to feminism. Any time any discussion gets just a bit too close to criticism of feminism or women in general, it always ends up shut down. Menslib just cannot handle that, and any man (any who hasn't drunk the kool-aid yet) will see this and recognize Menslib just doesn't have their best interest at heart.	/r/PurplePillDebate	24/07/24 06:19 PM
11	Liberals politicians support adding women to Selective Service Men get (sexually) assaulted in the military all the time, yet no one uses that as an argument for making men exempt from the draft.	/r/PurplePillDebate	20/06/24 11:08 PM
3	Korean men are turning to AI to get dates for them as men haven’t made the necessary changes to themselves and society Men in Korea are still forced into conscription during the prime years of their lives. Maybe first force women to do so as well, and then you can start to talk about men "needing" to change.	/r/PurplePillDebate	20/06/24 11:05 PM
1	A good way to incentivize more women to have children. Would be guaranteeing that women could continue to chase their dreams as well. integrity, empathy, care for others -- those things that give you self-respect and make life worth living Parents should have all that for their children, and that is why they should put their dreams and ambitions on hold for the benefit of their children. You are basically asking random people to sacrifice their dreams in the name of "empathy" while letting parents off the hook for having none for their own offspring.	/r/PurplePillDebate	19/06/24 10:53 PM
–	Does Agreeableness Actually Matter? Agreeableness covers a lot more than just being "submissive" and it's also used as an actual term in psychology. Women consistently score higher on agreeableness than men.	/r/PurplePillDebate	22/04/24 09:17 AM
2	Late stage feminism leads to population collapse It's not the smaller population that's a problem, it's the inverted young/elderly population collapse that will cause collapse. You are right that we will adapt, but every indication thus far means a replacement of any progressive values by traditional religious ones, as those groups far outbreed progressives.	/r/PurplePillDebate	07/04/24 02:19 PM
-1	Late stage feminism leads to population collapse Some (Western) countries are seeing a collapse, not just a decrease.	/r/PurplePillDebate	07/04/24 01:59 PM
10	Late stage feminism leads to population collapse Once the boomers are dead, the population issues will calm down. No it won't. The current population crunch is going to hit the current young generations (Millennials and Zoomers) the hardest. Look at South Korea's 0.68 birth rate; that's a population contraction of 75% each generation	/r/PurplePillDebate	07/04/24 01:32 PM
4	Do men feel less guilty about dating autistic people compared to women? There is evidence that male autists reproduce at far lower rate than female autists. But that's fertility, not so much dating.	/r/PurplePillDebate	20/03/24 10:01 PM
21	Men shouldn't dismiss so quickly the idea that unequal distribution of housework/childcare contributes to divorces Taking subreddits as an accurate representation of reality is baffling. You could just as easily conclude that women simply complain more.	/r/PurplePillDebate	04/03/24 06:48 PM
1	Why do people pretend the only thing men had to offer was a paycheck? Not having to be drafted to fight and die, for example.	/r/PurplePillDebate	02/03/24 10:54 AM
6	Why do people pretend the only thing men had to offer was a paycheck? Collapse of birth rates followed by a return to traditional gender roles.	/r/PurplePillDebate	02/03/24 10:50 AM
13	My explanation of the manosphere popularity I agree, it would be great to not have to do that. Unfortunately, men's rights advocates and red pillers have so thoroughly tainted the pool with virulent misogyny that men feel the need to distance themselves from them. Doesnt really matter if they have or not, them being unapologetically male will have gotten them labeled "misogynistic" anyway. Theyre not any more vitriolic to the opposite gender than TwoX is, yet that gets a pass. Menslib doesn't need to distance themselves from those groups,…	/r/PurplePillDebate	18/02/24 05:38 PM
23	My explanation of the manosphere popularity B) I have repeatedly offered r/MensLib to men here only to get screamed at about how terrible they are because they don't allow posters to just baselessly blame women and feminism for all of men's problems. No, Menslib is terrible because it barely offers anything in terms of solutions, and it's filled with groveling auto-flagellants who have to preface everything with "i'm not a MRA, but" or "I don't want to invalidate women's experiences, but". But the main issue with Menslib is that it simply…	/r/PurplePillDebate	18/02/24 04:06 PM
7	Do most women really dislike being approached in general? It's why you should just disregard their advice completely. Sure you might make a couple uncomfortable by approaching when they don't wnat to, but it's better than never risking anything and thus getting nothing.	/r/PurplePillDebate	18/01/24 02:10 PM
–	CMV, women have a low tolerance for male vulnerability which perpetuates men not expressing their thoughts and feelings You really are just making baseless assumptions based on absolutely nothing. Are you seeing a psychiatrist for this?	/r/PurplePillDebate	04/01/24 09:40 PM
–	CMV, women have a low tolerance for male vulnerability which perpetuates men not expressing their thoughts and feelings He showed vulnerability and was naturally punished for it.	/r/PurplePillDebate	04/01/24 09:31 PM
2	From a cold, practical perspective isn't women's emancipation bad for society if it leads to low birth rates The cultures i was referring to don't see women as "breeding machines" either; they simply see childbirth as its own reward and natural. But that is enough to already make them more fecund than secularized and more progressive populations. It's not a conscious effort for them to "outbreed" others; it's just a natural consequence of their way of living.	/r/PurplePillDebate	18/12/23 11:56 AM
–	From a cold, practical perspective isn't women's emancipation bad for society if it leads to low birth rates I mean, there are plenty of cultures who do believe that, and they will outbreed liberal ones. If that means progressive values die out as a result of that, then oh well.	/r/PurplePillDebate	17/12/23 03:04 PM
1	From a cold, practical perspective isn't women's emancipation bad for society if it leads to low birth rates None of the attempts at increasing birth rates through economic means have succeeded. Even if some communist utopia would be achieved, it's unlikely it wouldn't just get outbred by cultural conservatives.	/r/PurplePillDebate	17/12/23 03:02 PM
2	From a cold, practical perspective isn't women's emancipation bad for society if it leads to low birth rates Amish double every year and their retention rate is 90%. The only way they can feasibly stop this is when they have pretty much taken over all of the US' farmland, at which point they will already be a majority. There is also very little incentive for the US government to curtail their birthrates, because new manpower will be desperately needed as global fertility rates drop.	/r/PurplePillDebate	17/12/23 02:44 PM
3	From a cold, practical perspective isn't women's emancipation bad for society if it leads to low birth rates Population decline is a massive economic issue. Look at South Korea's 0.8 fertility rate, for example. That number spells complete disaster for any society.	/r/PurplePillDebate	17/12/23 02:33 PM
1	From a cold, practical perspective isn't women's emancipation bad for society if it leads to low birth rates The link between birth rates and economics is very weak, it's mostly a cultural issue. Even the most generous support programs can barely cause an increase in birth rates in western social democracies.	/r/PurplePillDebate	17/12/23 02:32 PM
1	From a cold, practical perspective isn't women's emancipation bad for society if it leads to low birth rates It is, which is why such societies will be outbred by societies that are vehemently against emancipation.	/r/PurplePillDebate	17/12/23 02:31 PM
1	What really changed I spent three paragraphs on it because you spent three paragraphs talking about something that supposedly doesn't concern or bother you in any way. But sure, we'll leave it at that.	/r/PurplePillDebate	04/12/23 05:48 PM
0	What really changed It's not aimed at you personally, but more at progressive in general; you have to realize that there are consequences for emancipation. You can have your sexcual freedom, you can be free from the yoke of reproduction, but this also means you are surrendering the future to those who do reproduce at high rates. Also this isn't really far in the future; it's like a couple of generations away. This "after me the deluge" attitude is perfectly fine by me because i don't particularly care about progres…	/r/PurplePillDebate	04/12/23 05:20 PM
1	What really changed Yeah i don't really get it either. People keep saying "oh conservatives need to adapt to modern dating or else they won't reproduce, you need liberal values nowadays to have a woman interested in you". Mean while progressive fertility numbers hover around 1 while the Amish population doubles every 20 years. I suppose Amish aren't contributing a lot to global warming.	/r/PurplePillDebate	04/12/23 05:01 PM
2	What really changed That's fine, but you have to realize that this means that the future will belong to populations who do reproduce, which will be religious ultraconservatives. Once those groups reach a significant population, they will have enough political weight to start abolishing progressive constructs like abortion, no-fault divorce, etc.	/r/PurplePillDebate	04/12/23 12:00 PM