TheRedArchive

~ archived since 2018 ~

Shuttup_Heather Archive

View 0 posts and 34 comments by Shuttup_Heather on TheRedPill subreddit and various other subreddits related to The Red Pill community.
Search in:
In subreddits:
More
Filter by year/month:
Upvotes Title Category Author Subreddit Date (UTC)
Upvotes Comment on Subreddit Date (UTC)
-1

Men’s rights isn’t going to destroy capitalism, it’s just dividing us further when you think feminism is what’s causing your issues to go unnoticed. It’s the billionaires ruining your lives.
/r/MensRights08/11/25 12:35 AM
1

You say partriarchy, I say the capitalist boot that’s on all of our throats. We all suffer in different ways. No one said that men have perfect lives and if that’s what you take away from the word “patriarchy” then I’m sorry I have little conversation to have with someone so obtuse. Good day.
/r/MensRights08/11/25 12:34 AM
-20

I find that a lot of people on here display incel like behavior and attitudes towards women. I also look down upon subreddits with similar behavior from women, like TERFs. Anyone here for genuine concern for the lives of human beings and not just to spread hate is okay in my book—sadly I see a lot of hate.
/r/MensRights08/11/25 12:32 AM
-4

Are you blaming me for this? You need help if you are
/r/MensRights08/11/25 12:29 AM
1

We can’t advocate for body autonomy for one gender and gender equality for all. So the two battles of genital mutilation can’t be separate for anyone who truly believes in those values. I’m sad to hear you don’t think we should fight each others battles. I think we’re stronger undivided by arbitrary things. We should focus on working class unity and forgo a lot of the needless debates like what new name to call our movements that have existed for decades.
/r/MensRights08/11/25 12:23 AM
-1

Yep feminism is equal rights regardless of gender If you wouldn’t support an intersex, trans person, you’re not a feminist. Gender has nothing to do with who gets support and who doesn’t
/r/MensRights07/11/25 10:26 PM
-2

She’s not educated on circumcision or body autonomy it seems, and you can’t take an uneducated persons opinion as evidence for the mindset of many well educated feminists. Customs are changing and many young people are against circumcision.
/r/MensRights07/11/25 10:25 PM
8

That’s actually sexist of you and you’re proving their point. Please don’t call yourself a feminist if you’re going to downplay others issues
/r/MensRights07/11/25 10:23 PM
0

I’d advocate against genital mutilation regardless of gender. Because gender equality is the basis of feminism. What I meant to say is feminism has already given you the platform to talk about issues regarding or pertaining to your gender. So why are you so keen to set yourself apart from a movement that has already actively been fighting for your equality. My point is feminism has been talking about genital mutilation, consent, body autonomy for a long time. Why do you feel the need to make the…
/r/MensRights07/11/25 09:50 PM
-4

They just want an excuse to say feminism is bad without understanding it at all
/r/MensRights07/11/25 09:34 PM
-18

No feminist would say all men are privileged. Gay men certainly aren’t, and I wouldn’t say all cis men are. You guys are making many assumptions about all feminists.
/r/MensRights07/11/25 09:33 PM
-38

No because it’s not women’s job to make more of a platform for body autonomy—women have already done a lot of work for advocating for the right of choosing what happens to your body. And consent. Both are issues feminism talks about a lot. They’ve given you the tools and terms to talk about your body autonomy, and we’re listening and also advocating alongside you.
/r/MensRights07/11/25 09:32 PM
-4

Hey feminist here and I do care about circumcision and talk about it. It isn’t up to women to make a platform for your issues—as a man you, you have the ability to talk about things like consent and body autonomy. These are topics that women have already made it more comfortable to talk about, and have reaffirmed that everyone has a right to body autonomy. While you can assume most women are strictly talking about their own body autonomy, we are not—we believe we ALL deserve the right to choose …
/r/MensRights07/11/25 09:30 PM
1

China valued men over women for years, because they could pass on their name and provide for the elders. Girl babies were not favored at all when the one-child policy came around, so I don’t think the anomaly is women being valued over men. I think we can just blame gender roles. It’s old-fashioned beliefs that based on your gender you’re either the strong bread winner or a loving caretaker (like a mom), that you can only fit into certain roles and if you don’t you’re not a “real man/woman” I th…
/r/MensRights15/09/20 01:33 PM
1

I’ve known what you meant and have understood your pint, I feel like your misinterpreting mine. Also more men are in politics so what’s inaccurate or wrong about me saying that men were the ones to pass legislature? Why do I have to say it was the upper class. Because I’m making it a gendered issue by stating a fact? The subject of the post is already very gendered, or whatever the heck the phrase is. Why are you insisting I have say “all humans were oppressed” instead of saying what I have to s…
/r/MensRights10/09/20 12:15 AM
1

It’s that just citizens being oppressed as a whole? I’m talking about oppression that’s specifically targeting a group of people, not just society as a whole being oppressed by the upper class. That’d be a different topic I think. I brought up America and the 19th amendment cause they were specifically excluded from voting until that point in time. No ones saying men were never oppressed at any point in time, all people have been oppressed at one time or another. I’m just saying that at a time m…
/r/MensRights09/09/20 12:48 PM
1

But African Americans arent asking for it to be removed so why even suggest that, and Sandra Day O’Connor saves affirmative action because it isn’t racist. Idc if you disagree, they deserve reparations for years of continuing systematic oppression. If you want black people to be disproportionately poorer and less educated than white people for a longer time, getting rid of affirmative action is a step in that direction. Sorry your ancestors were enslaved, a lot of our ancestors were enslaved. Bu…
/r/MensRights09/09/20 12:12 PM
0

I’m not choosing to look through any kind of lens. I know how many women are in the senate and House of Representatives, they only make up 1/4 of both. Women weren’t the law makers in the past, and there aren’t enough women in politics currently to say that they get an equal vote in legislature. Not saying that it has to be 50/50 to be fair, just pointing out that there’s way more men in politics than women rn. The gender gap is still huge.
/r/MensRights09/09/20 12:02 PM
1

Yeah both men and women can be against abortion, but it’s fair for me to say that it’s men making the laws surrounding it. Women only make up 23% of the House of Representatives, and 25% of the senate. For example 25 male republicans voted to outlaw abortion in Alabama. I didn’t really understand what you meant about the birth control though, sorry
/r/MensRights09/09/20 06:26 AM
1

Okay, but that’s kinda different than what we’re talking about. We were talking about BLM, I don’t see people going out in the name of BLM killing people regularly on the news. If violence occurs, it’s not because the movement as a whole is a violent one. There’s no reason for a normal white person in America to fear the BLM movement here. I’ve had protests going on in my state and yeah they’ll get out of hand, but I’m not fearing for my life cause I think there’s gonna be a race war and some bl…
/r/MensRights09/09/20 01:33 AM
0

As fun as I found your hypothetical, I don’t see how anything you’ve said can relate to anything at all I said previously. I know you’re just adding it in there for whatever reason, but it wasn’t an actual response to the content of anything I said. So yeah, I think I’ve said all I wanted to and made myself as clear as I could. Have a nice night
/r/MensRights09/09/20 01:20 AM
1

I think the stuff going on in other countries is totally pertinent to the subject of whether or not women are oppressed, but referring to your other comment to another person I’d say that I can’t claim to know exactly what women in the past experienced. I know a lot more modern day examples, as I’m very focused on current news. I know that women are more likely to die from childbirth in the US (not oppression per se, but is anything be done about it? No, maternal mortality rates are rising here)…
/r/MensRights09/09/20 12:58 AM
-4

Only if you think all of your problems are to blame on those things, yeah. But reality is, it’s not gonna ruin the lives of a bunch of white people or leave them behind. It’s not meant as a way to get back at whitey, it’s only to help minorities. Sorry if you don’t like affirmative action, but there’s no evidence that it’s leaving whites at a disadvantage.
/r/MensRights09/09/20 12:24 AM
-1

I’m not saying the sister shouldn’t change her views—I simply said that it’s not inaccurate to say women were oppressed, which the commenter was totally implying they were not. I never said women can or should be sexist to men if you actually read anything I wrote.
/r/MensRights08/09/20 03:22 PM
-2

Voting was just the biggest, US based answer I could think of off the top of my head this early in the morning. Women still are horribly oppressed in other countries, I could list a lot of things going on currently but I don’t see the point as I’m sure you all already know about child brides, female genital mutilation, girls missing school in Africa because of the stigma around their period, the fact that China has a shortage of women now because of the one-child policy and a tradition that pref…
/r/MensRights08/09/20 03:09 PM
-5

I said saying women were oppressed is accurate cause they were, not they had it worse off than any other group around or that everyone besides them was privileged. I’m not sorry if you disagree
/r/MensRights08/09/20 02:40 PM
-1

I’m not saying that we should have a oppressor/oppressed view of society, that’s unhealthy. But it sounds like he’s disregarding that being a woman had a lot of disadvantages in the past because of a system that was controlled by men, which is just ignoring history and that’s not good for anyone. So I’m just staying on topic with what the post and comments are talking about, I’m not advocating that women label themselves as oppressed. Just reminding him that women weren’t allowed to vote until 1…
/r/MensRights08/09/20 01:17 PM
-11

No ones saying you have to eat shit and pay for the injustices that past Americans caused, but saying blacks have to pull themselves up by their own bootstraps is why I’m saying you’re lucky they don’t want revenge. What’s wrong with them getting a little bit of help? Things like affirmative action being called reverse-racism is said by people who think they’re gonna have a harder time getting into college cause their spots gonna get taken up by a Hispanic kid when that isn’t the case and it is …
/r/MensRights08/09/20 01:06 PM
-3

Okay you can call “fair share” a buzzword (I’m talking equal employment/pay, black women don’t die in hospitals more than white women, affordable housing, affordable healthcare, an equal chance to enter college to name a few) but you’re just calling your own reading comprehension poor if you say I listed nothing but buzzwords and that there was no real content to anything I said—the comment I replied to sounded paranoid as fuck about BLM, and that’s why I said what I said.
/r/MensRights08/09/20 12:50 PM
-1

You can’t just say “modern day feminism” is all bad when there are different kinds of feminism. Radical feminism isn’t the new feminism, they just happen to be the loudest and the ones that go viral.
/r/MensRights08/09/20 12:32 PM
-14

Are you saying black people haven’t been oppressed? You’re lucky black people want equality and not revenge, but stop acting like they’re all out to get you. They just want to be treated as equals and not have people say they’re asking for too much when they just want their fair share.
/r/MensRights08/09/20 12:26 PM
-7

Why should she consider what things were like for men in the past when men were the oppressors? “Men are better than women” is definitely not the brand of feminism I subscribe to as I find it sexist and dividing, but to say “men had it just as tough” isn’t necessarily wrong to say but men were the law makers, the husbands who were allowed to own property and vote for the laws the law makers made. Women were unable to change their situation. So, same question in reverse that you suggested he ask …
/r/MensRights08/09/20 12:23 PM
1

Okay but the thing is that in the past most places of business were only for men to work at—so saying it in the reverse means nothing because women were actually not allowed to have the same jobs as men and there probably would’ve been only men working there in the past. He just missed out cause they wanted to diversify (again, women weren’t allowed to get certain jobs before so I think extra consideration for women is fair to help us get ahead) or he wasn’t qualified enough to begin with since …
/r/MensRights08/09/20 11:51 AM
0

Ah yes, I feel so privileged to have my access to an abortion limited yet live in a first-world country where the maternal mortality rate is rising so that I’m more likely to die in child birth in the US than in another developed country. You know men and women really aren’t equal yet, the ERA never passed and as long as pregnant women are still dying in the hospital when 2/3’s of the deaths preventable, I would say don’t call us more privileged than men. Repeating affirmative action would affec…
/r/MensRights08/09/20 11:44 AM
You can kill a man, but you can't kill an idea.

© TheRedArchive 2026. All rights reserved.
created by /u/dream-hunter