TheRedArchive

~ archived since 2018 ~

advice_scaminal Archive

View 19 posts and 32 comments by advice_scaminal on TheRedPill subreddit and various other subreddits related to The Red Pill community.
Search in:
In subreddits:
More
Filter by year/month:
Upvotes Title Category Author Subreddit Date (UTC)
380

advice_scaminal/r/MensRights15/03/13 11:51 AM
285

advice_scaminal/r/MensRights23/03/13 11:51 AM
245

advice_scaminal/r/TheRedPill20/05/15 04:25 PM
199

Metaadvice_scaminal/r/TheRedPill03/06/15 03:38 PM
104

advice_scaminal/r/MensRights11/09/13 10:59 AM
75

advice_scaminal/r/MensRights14/06/13 03:28 PM
72

Red Pill Theoryadvice_scaminal/r/TheRedPill21/10/14 06:01 PM
52

advice_scaminal/r/MensRights15/08/13 06:51 PM
33

advice_scaminal/r/MensRights26/05/13 04:31 PM
25

advice_scaminal/r/MensRights14/07/13 07:39 PM
20

advice_scaminal/r/MensRights10/12/14 08:04 AM
18

advice_scaminal/r/MensRights20/08/13 06:42 AM
13

advice_scaminal/r/MensRights31/05/13 06:35 PM
9

Red Pill Theoryadvice_scaminal/r/TheRedPill09/07/15 05:28 PM
5

advice_scaminal/r/MensRights13/06/13 05:45 AM
2

advice_scaminal/r/MensRights05/08/13 09:33 PM
1

advice_scaminal/r/MensRights21/10/14 05:00 PM
0

Red Pill Exampleadvice_scaminal/r/TheRedPill19/08/18 06:30 PM
0

advice_scaminal/r/MensRights24/05/14 08:41 PM
Upvotes Comment on Subreddit Date (UTC)
5

That describes 70% of women for you. I'd say that's low. each person is unique. Of course each person is unique. But Peterson is similar enough to the other mainstream manosphere snake oil salesmen. That's why he's so popular. Looks like you are the one who's triggered by me mentioning him and are projecting your own insecurities onto me. Do the work, brother.
/r/TheRedPill28/03/25 11:20 PM
12

Women who are actually on a journey of self improvement don't talk about it. There's a lot of social pressure on women to stay where they are in terms of growth - far more than there is on men. Of course, it also exists for men too, which is why you often have to find new friends when you start changing who you are. A woman who is leveling up is typically careful to keep it to herself, unless it's part of it is something socially recognized, like getting a degree or changing jobs. Women can leve…
/r/TheRedPill28/03/25 10:35 PM
5

Yeah huge parts of this post are just straight up abuse. And this exactly what red-pill haters will paint the entire community as advocating, using this poster's words.
/r/TheRedPill05/07/21 05:33 AM
2

This is one of the best business/financial posts I have read here. So refreshing to see something beyond the standard "use game to get ahead in your corporate job" stuff.
/r/TheRedPill01/05/20 08:26 PM
4

Best comment in this thread right here.
/r/TheRedPill17/01/20 10:30 AM
2

Name makes perfect sense if you believe "good" = "feminine".
/r/TheRedPill27/11/18 04:55 AM
6

Eh if your boss was a gay dude and he gave you a dildo as a xmas gift because you need to "learn to take it in the ass", how would you feel?
/r/TheRedPill03/11/18 05:37 AM
1

Yeah the guy's game is terrible, but this is India so the standards are much lower. And of course you are right that game doesn't matter since he's hot. But notice her hamstering about his approach? She wanted to suck him off "just to thank him for restoring my faith in men." Riiiight.
/r/TheRedPill19/08/18 06:58 PM
1

Lol, fucking Mystery and Ross Jeffries ruined PUA. They commercialized the shit out of it and made it look stupid. And then Neil Strauss, Tyler Durden, and Nick Savoy (all students of Mystery) after them. PUA would have evolved very differently place if men like Zan or MrSex4yNYC were the face of pickup. Instead it's a dude wearing a tophot, snowboarding goggles, and black painted fingernails.
/r/TheRedPill25/08/17 01:29 AM
5

Very good post. The scientific basis of psychopathy is actually incredibly vague and fuzzy. If you haven't seen it, this TED talk questioning the method of diagnosing psychopathy is a must-see.
/r/TheRedPill04/06/15 05:53 PM
3

Thanks for reapproving. The article does have a significant anecdotal component, but it is not of the "short" or "uninformative" kind. This writer clearly has been "saving up his stories and anecdotes" for several years and has "arrived at a cogent conclusion", "including the data of multiple experiences at once as a basis for [his] conclusions", just as your guidelines suggest.
/r/TheRedPill03/06/15 08:44 PM
5

This is the exact opposite of an anecdote. An anecdote would be this, or this (both of which are currently in the top 10 right now). I linked to a well-thought article on current trends in intellectual and political discourse that was highly relevant to the ideas discussed on this sub. No other moderator had an issue with it, and as I previously pointed out, the vast majority of votes were positive, as were all of the comments. I thought redpill was about encouraging open debate, not the kind of…
/r/TheRedPill03/06/15 07:48 PM
5

Why was this removed?
/r/TheRedPill03/06/15 06:23 PM
1

I thought this was particularly interesting comment coming from the source. When far-left magazines are talking about MR issues, things are starting to change.
/r/MensRights10/12/14 08:47 PM
1

It's interesting that many of the comments have focused on whether that one statement is precisely true rather than whether my characterization of the concept of slut-shaming is accurate. The influx of new subscribers has made TRP far too concerned with the image that it projects to blue pillers. I'd rather see debate on the merits of the concept rather than what most current subscribers think about the wording.
/r/TheRedPill21/10/14 10:55 PM
0

I don't give a shit about "TRP-represented". If you see TRP as a doctrine then it's just another form of blue-pill thinking. The concept of the red pill is liberation from indoctrination. TRP is really becoming TPP these days.
/r/TheRedPill21/10/14 07:55 PM
4

A good woman will amongst other things cook, clean and tend to your household, a significant resource to any man who values his time. So will a maid working at close to minimum wage.
/r/TheRedPill21/10/14 07:53 PM
5

Why? Do you actually have a reason or is it just your visceral response to an idea that you find distasteful?
/r/TheRedPill21/10/14 07:00 PM
2

I disagree. They can offer a lot more than just a vagina. If it was, wives would be very uncommon. When placed next to a man they only offer slightly different things, but that's not to say that they don't still offer the other stuff. You really think that many men don't get married primarily for the promise (often unfulfilled) of access to regular reliable sex?
/r/TheRedPill21/10/14 06:59 PM
2

I will delete and resubmit.
/r/MensRights17/09/13 06:36 PM
1

See my previous comment. The article itself is very fair and well-written. I take issue with the editor that wrote the title ("It's a man's world") and the subsequent tagline ("Can perpetrators of violence against women play a role in preventing it and to what extent can early intervention help?"). Neither of those make much sense in the context of what the article actually says. Can perpetrators of murder play a role in preventing it? The question is asinine. Whoever wrote those seems to be adv…
/r/MensRights12/09/13 12:03 PM
7

Excellent article, terrible title.
/r/MensRights11/09/13 10:59 AM
2

Yes I think you are right. That also explains the part about losing his place at Harvard. Reading through his webpage and Wikipedia, one would think he graduated, but it never actually says that, only that he "attended." Perhaps he was kicked out over this and is trying to cover that up elsewhere, even as he is revealing it here to gain sympathy. Reading the more recent comments in this and the other threads he started, it seems that there is far more to this case than Mr. Alahverdian would like…
/r/MensRights16/08/13 04:51 PM
0

Yes, because some MRAs also happen to be losers it means the movement can't possibly be worth supporting. And if you think that essay is the "most disparaging" towards MRAs then you obviously are not at all familiar with the extensive criticism of the movement, the vast majority of which is far harsher. Look around this subreddit a bit and you can find some examples.
/r/MensRights16/08/13 02:59 PM

Very misleading title. This link is from the guy's own website. According to his bio, he graduated from Harvard and has had a very successful career. It doesn't seem like his life has been destroyed. I also don't understand why he didn't get himself a more competent attorney in the first place. A lot of this story doesn't make sense. EDIT: read his wikipedia entry for a more sensical and balanced overview of this man and the case in question
/r/MensRights16/08/13 09:20 AM
0

Yes, of course I am dying to be accepted by you and a bunch of other people on the internet that I have never met. And you wonder why people characterize you as losers. It couldn't possibly have anything to do with your words and actions, could it?
/r/MensRights16/08/13 06:37 AM
-1

You and the other people responding on this thread make some good points that I agree with, however since my comments have been heavily downvoted I won't continue this discussion any further. Obviously, the circlejerk here has no interest in any debate that does not reinforce what they already believe. I won't bother wasting my time.
/r/MensRights16/08/13 06:26 AM
-4

There's risk and reward to everything. A man who is capable of achieving financial and career success should not have a difficult time learning to tell the difference between a woman who will exploit him and one who will not. Generally speaking, success with women comes easier than financial success.
/r/MensRights15/08/13 09:00 PM
-6

I have never heard of this movement but based on what Wikipedia says about it I would say that it seems at least as bad as MGTOW. I can understand the male perspective more easily and in many cases I think MGTOW are backwards-rationalizing their failure with women as a "choice" they are making when in reality the only choice they have made is to give up trying because that's the easier option. It's actually not that hard to get women if you want them, but you do have to accept them on their own …
/r/MensRights15/08/13 08:26 PM
-10

I must confess that I agree with the author's bias against MGTOW.
/r/MensRights15/08/13 08:08 PM
0

Yeah me too, seems to be prevalent around here.
/r/MensRights15/06/13 06:23 AM
9

Rioting in the streets has nothing to do with the "traditional views" of anarchism.
/r/MensRights29/05/13 07:46 PM
You can kill a man, but you can't kill an idea.

© TheRedArchive 2026. All rights reserved.
created by /u/dream-hunter