There were these two attractive blondes (roommates) at the bar, and after chatting them up for a while I discovered that they were both cool, funny, and definitely flirting with me. After about 15 minutes of attraction stuff, I wasn't sure which girl I should go for, and the fact that I couldn't decide was distracting me from getting either one. I ended up choosing the girl with better hands.

Over the course of the next 90 minutes, the roommate I didn't choose brought up string theory and the fact that she blazes like all the time. The one I chose was ok, but the chemistry was just so-so. I walked her home, got the digits, and we kissed. After waking up this morning, I realized that I'm crazy for the other roommate.

This happens to me all the time. After opening up the set I can't decide which girl I want (visualizing a threeway is not helpful), and choosing the wrong girl is almost always a fatal mistake.

What can I do to focus on the right girl? In my current situation, how can I maneuver the old switcheroo with these roommates?