TheRedArchive

~ archived since 2018 ~

CritiquingFeminism Archive

View 18 posts and 25 comments by CritiquingFeminism on TheRedPill subreddit and various other subreddits related to The Red Pill community.
Search in:
In subreddits:
More
Filter by year/month:
Upvotes Title Category Author Subreddit Date (UTC)
272

GeneralCritiquingFeminism/r/MensRights03/07/25 01:27 AM
164

GeneralCritiquingFeminism/r/MensRights09/01/26 11:48 PM
123

DiscriminationCritiquingFeminism/r/MensRights25/01/25 04:43 AM
105

HealthCritiquingFeminism/r/MensRights27/03/25 11:45 PM
92

articleCritiquingFeminism/r/LeftWingMaleAdvocates11/02/26 06:13 AM
72

articleCritiquingFeminism/r/LeftWingMaleAdvocates29/01/26 01:34 AM
68

articleCritiquingFeminism/r/LeftWingMaleAdvocates02/04/26 01:03 AM
65

GeneralCritiquingFeminism/r/MensRights21/09/25 05:41 AM
64

GeneralCritiquingFeminism/r/MensRights31/03/26 03:06 AM
60

articleCritiquingFeminism/r/LeftWingMaleAdvocates04/06/26 03:58 AM
58

FeminismCritiquingFeminism/r/MensRights29/06/25 01:23 AM
56

GeneralCritiquingFeminism/r/MensRights30/07/25 12:52 AM
52

GeneralCritiquingFeminism/r/MensRights29/05/26 10:36 PM
43

Edu./Occu.CritiquingFeminism/r/MensRights09/03/25 03:07 AM
42

GeneralCritiquingFeminism/r/MensRights27/08/25 04:40 AM
32

GeneralCritiquingFeminism/r/MensRights07/02/26 10:31 PM
27

GeneralCritiquingFeminism/r/MensRights18/02/25 03:03 AM
1

Legal RightsCritiquingFeminism/r/MensRights06/03/25 07:54 AM
Upvotes Comment on Subreddit Date (UTC)
174

I just watched the linked video & I am appalled. When the Senator asked why men aren’t among their 15 priority groups despite making up more than ¾ of suicides, they dissembled. When the Senator asked why, over a time when global suicide rates declined by 36%, Australia’s only moved by 1% they essentially just shrugged. Anyone who cared would have responded “That’s terrible. We need to fix it.” Instead, we got evasion. PS: One of them conjectured that perhaps global suicide rates are higher. I c…
/r/MensRights04/06/26 03:23 AM
9

Short answer - Yes. FWIW I wrote an essay looking at this from the other side: What's the result of people caring more about women? See >Here<
/r/MensRights18/03/26 11:43 AM
40

That got my attention as well. Just before, they say: International human rights law establishes formal equality, also known as de jure equality, as a foundational principle, mandating that practices, policies and laws apply to men and women, and boys and girls, in a gender-neutral manner. And then they say "formal equality must go beyond identical treatment..." My reading is that laws mandate formal equality. They can't change that. So, let's redefine formal equality to mean discrimination.
/r/MensRights17/02/26 04:31 AM
3

One final response. Let me just address your first 3 sentences. >I made my position rather clear. In truth, you still haven’t answered the central question of whether feminism conflicts with liberalism. And you also duck the key evidence of its opposition to individual rights, tolerance and the rule of law. >You are lionizing the ideals of classic liberalism… As the essay explicitly says I use the broadest definition of liberalism - not classical liberalism in particular. You didn't read it care…
/r/LeftWingMaleAdvocates13/02/26 04:53 AM
3

I'm not clear what you are disagreeing with... I argue there's tension between feminism and liberalism. Are you claiming there is no tension? Or is your concern about the portrayal of feminism?
/r/LeftWingMaleAdvocates12/02/26 10:59 PM
6

Sadly, the terminology is awful. I do argue that (polsci) liberalism should be defended. Unfortunately, especially in the US, “liberal” generally refers to the political left. And I'm critical of today’s left since it's overwhelmingly feminist. Ironically, the result is they have become illiberal though still often labelled "liberal".
/r/MensRights08/02/26 05:49 AM
2

Interesting point. But I'm struggling to see the uniqueness of American feminism. It shows the same characteristics as feminism elsewhere: prejudice, discrimination, dehumanisation etc. And the same beliefs. To me, one of the striking things about feminism is its homogeneity across very different cultures - quite different right-wing equivalents. I worry a bit that your response could be read as trying to excuse American feminists their faults on the grounds that their attacks are just backlash …
/r/MensRights28/08/25 12:32 AM
2

In the essay I sketch historic links between women's liberation and the radical left. Those links led to feminist academia using elements of Marxist theory. In turn, this has led some critics to identify feminism as Marxist. But, like you, I beg to differ.
/r/MensRights27/08/25 11:45 PM
3

FYI I plan a future essay on feminism as left wing authoritarianism. I'm interested in your reference to social dominance theory. I'm no expert but my understanding is that it is blind to left wing authoritarianism and more or less assumes a patriarchy. How do you see it as relevant?
/r/MensRights27/08/25 11:39 PM
6

Interesting. That's consistent with the findings of this study. But when you compare countries, you get the opposite result - male relative disadvantage is larger in rich countries. Hmm....
/r/MensRights03/07/25 03:40 AM
1

Thank you. Genuinely appreciated
/r/MensRights29/06/25 11:07 PM
2

Thank you. Genuinely appreciated
/r/MensRights29/06/25 11:07 PM
6

Thanks for the kind words. Cheers
/r/MensRights05/06/25 10:09 AM
5

The outcome of the proof of concept was what we have today. And, as the article argues, any fleeting commitment to equality could only pass. It was always going to end up like this. Read the article! Cheers
/r/MensRights05/06/25 07:22 AM
7

I'm pretty sure that there would be no place for her views today. In the early days, when feminism was weak, equality was was a useful short term objective. Now things have moved on & there's no longer a place for equality or for any who support it. And it was always going to end up this way because feminism was always going to become an Us-vs-Them ideology. It could never be anything else.
/r/MensRights05/06/25 06:42 AM
3

You say: Plus I don’t think things will ever change or get better for males. No ideology like feminism has ever lasted for ever. Sooner or later people understand the injustice.
/r/MensRights27/05/25 07:16 AM
3

In my opinion this rationalisation is flawed: A fundamental problem is that it assumes an equivalence between women today and ancestral women. Why? I have just as many female ancestors as women do. Shouldn’t I also receive privilege rather than be penalised? To particularise this point, if the ABC journalist’s grandfather “hogged space” to the cost of my grandmother, shouldn’t it be the journalist who is penalised? At root, this is a doctrine of original sin – men are guilty by virtue of birth r…
/r/MensRights06/05/25 05:41 AM
4

Hi I'm the author. Just wanted to say thanks so much for your kind words. These essays are a lot of work & the encouragement is helpful. Cheers Tony
/r/MensRights22/04/25 12:01 AM
31

Summary Doing bad things but using the language of virtue has been common for centuries. Psychologists, writers and philosophers have discussed, analysed and lamented the phenomenon at length. In this essay, I steal their ideas and apply them to DEI, Gender Equality and other feminist policies including: Why is an all-female work force diverse? How can excluding men be called inclusive? Why is discrimination labelled Gender Equality? Why do you get called a misogynist if you point out discrimina…
/r/MensRights30/03/25 06:54 AM
1

I added that sentence at the urging of a reviewer who felt it would seem judicious. It's proven the only sentence with which people find fault! Useful lesson. Thanks for the encouraging words.
/r/MensRights09/03/25 04:32 AM
24

Summary of article: There's a problem at the core of feminism - group rights: · They lack a valid philosophical foundation. · They are inherently linked to discrimination. And · They expand without limit rather than stopping at equality, If the entire framework is flawed, why waste time debating feminist justifications built on it? Read article in full here -> What’s Wrong with Feminist Rights? Grateful for any comments, suggestions or questions. Cheers
/r/MensRights09/03/25 03:14 AM
1

Summary Group rights are at the core of feminism, yet they come with serious problems: They lack a valid philosophical foundation. They are inherently linked to discrimination. They expand without limit rather than stopping at equality If the entire framework is flawed, why waste time debating feminist justifications built on it? That’s the focus of my third Substack post! Interested to hear any comments, questions or suggestions. Cheers
/r/MensRights06/03/25 08:02 AM
10

Summary: Under feminism, women are favoured & men disadvantaged. Can that be justified? I look at the 3 most common justifications: Equality of Outcome fails as a way to redistribute resources to the needy, since it favours privileged women above needy men. It also undermines merit, is divisive & discriminatory. Women’s Rights probably aren’t what you think they are. They are conjured up on demand to provide privilege to women & are unrelated to any historical human rights. In fact, because male…
/r/MensRights18/02/25 03:05 AM
3

Advocates for women's reproductive rights often rely on Article 16 of the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women (CEDAW). But people always chop the bit they want to quote out of context. Let's put the relevant clause (E) back in some context: ...[E]nsure, on a basis of equality of men and women: ... (e) The same rights to decide freely and responsibly on the number and spacing of their children and to have access to the information, education and means to ena…
/r/MensRights31/01/25 10:19 PM
44

Summary: As an example of Feminist Gender Equality in practice, I recount World Food Program actions in Haiti where they withheld food from starving men in contravention of humanitarian standards. Analysis of Global Gender Gap Index and shows how death of Ukranian males in war has raised Ukraine to equal first place on life span. Looks at discrimination against males in Gender Equality organisations and initiatives. Feminist quotes admitting that Gender Equality is discrimination. Conclusion: Ge…
/r/MensRights25/01/25 04:46 AM
You can kill a man, but you can't kill an idea.

© TheRedArchive 2026. All rights reserved.
created by /u/dream-hunter