We list on this page the best book reviews websites available.

Methodology
This ranking is based on 500+ book reviews that we published and that we researched beforehand, comparing how others reviewed them and with a focus on:

• Critical thinking
• Reviewer expertise and track record
• Bias, incentives, and manipulation risks
• Usefulness for high-performing readers

Note: We focus on non-fiction books, mostly focusing on psychology, power, strategy, seduction/dating and men’s self-empowerment.

Intro: A List for Ambitious Men

Most book review sites are written for bibliophiles, hobbyists and fiction readers. This list is different.

If you are a high-agency man, your time is your most limited resource.
You don’t need “flowery prose” or “star ratings” from average readers; you need a Strategic Vetting that tells you if a book’s logic is sound and empowers you, or if it’s “naive self-help” that wastes your time.

Below is an audit of the best—and worst—sources for high-stakes non-fiction intelligence.

#6. Amazon

You might have heard of this one :).

Amazon is the most popular book review site.

I make a stop on Amazon for almost every single book review I write. First of all, because I get affiliate links from Amazon :). And once I’m there, I also always visit the review section.

With time I have learned the ins and outs of the system, and this is my opinion on Amazon as a book review site:

Pros

• Quantity of books: there is a review for almost any book out there
• Quantity of reviews: plenty of reviews for each book
• Sorting: I love the option of sorting by stars or by highest voted

Cons

• No expert reviewers: anyone can review on Amazon. That’s a bigger issue for information products than for, say, a vacuum cleaner.
• Average rating = average of average folks: most people are average, and few are experts. Average people are less likely to be power-aware, logical, and critical thinkers. And they’re more likely to fall -and mistakenly provide high ratings- to useless naive self-help
• Swayed by fans/hater reviewers: at Amazon, you don’t even need to buy a book to review it.  I’d be surprised if lots of reviewers didn’t even read the book, but only vented their opinion or supported a friend/idol (or trashed an enemy)
• Most fake reviews: since Amazon is mostly there to sell books, and not to review them, it also happens to be the most targeted by fake reviews. Including, of course, from the author themselves
• Smaller book reviews are completely unreliable: albeit all books have fake reviews, the less popular ones are the easiest to swarm with fake reviews
• Confirmation bias: people tend to buy what they like, so you get more fans and fewer critical reviews
• Not really a book review site: finally, Amazon reviews are not a content reviews section. Many conflate the book quality with the Amazon or seller service. You’ll often see 1-star reviews complaining about the book handling, shipping, or status. Those add up in the final rating.

I’ll give you an example that covers a lot of the cons of Amazon as a book review site: the book The Secret.

The Secret is a book that tells you not to work on your dreams and goals. Anyone in his right mind who wants to achieve his goals wouldn’t know what to do with such advice.
But The Secret is a best seller and it has a sky-high rating.

People who buy The Secret are probably already the law of attraction aficionados, so their ratings are as credible as Trump supporters on Trump’s mental fitness (or Clinton supporters on her pay-per-play habits, let’s not be partisans).

Overall:

A solid, all-season place to get book reviews from all sorts of readers. Just keep in mind the shortcomings (and the high number of fake reviews).

#5. Google Books

Google Books is smaller than Amazon, but I found the book reviews to be slightly better and more objective.

As an open, grassroots project, it has many of the same advantages and disadvantages as Amazon.
Such as:

Pros

• Higher quality reviews compared to Amazon

Cons

• Easily deceived, especially for smaller books. If you read a book like Published you will realize that in an open system, lots (most?) of the reviews can be fabricated.

#4. Goodreads

Goodreads is a social network of book reviews.

The idea is just awesome: you can write your own reviews, exchange opinions with friends, or simply just follow people you trust.

Pros

• You know the reviewers
• You can better target subject matter experts compared to Amazon/Google Books

Cons

• Facebook of books: I joined it with the idea of only following reviewers I liked, but I immediately got friend requests from pretty much all the Facebook friends who were also in there :)
• The best reviewers are not there: not all the top reviewers are on Goodreads because they have their own websites

#3. Derek Sivers

A successful entrepreneur and later solopreneur who lives life his way, Sivers reviews books without affiliations.

Pros

• Does not mince words
• He’s been a successful entrepreneur: he has the results to back his business book reviews

Cons

• No categories: summaries are all mixed on a single page, going from history to biographies to self-help

#2. Nat Eliason

Nat applies good logic and critical thinking, and he’s not afraid of calling things like they are.

I find that we often agree on many books -with some due exceptions-.
I discovered Nat’s website recently and I will soon be going through some of his top book picks that I haven’t yet read.

#1. The Power Moves

We review books through the lens of Power Dynamics and Social Engineering,

Pros

• The BS-Filter: We cross-reference claims against empirical evidence and real-world effectiveness

Cons

• More limited offering, we focus on power, strategies, seduction, psychology and smart men’s empowerment

Low-Utility Sites for High-Achievers

I didn’t find the following book review websites to be very good sources for prioritizing your reading list:

The New York Times

The New York Times reviews read more like a book themselves than book reviews and it sometimes focuses on literary merit and ‘narrative’ rather than actual content. That is useless for a man who needs to extract insights, frameworks, or strategies.

Most Book Review Websites

Most book review websites are for people who want to sit with a cup of coffee, a blanket on their feet, and a cat nearby.

These websites cater a lot to people who “read for reading’s sake”.

That doesn’t fit my goals and my audience’s goals. We read to improve, develop and move ahead in life -of course, most of us also love reading too, but it’s not the only motivator-.

General book review websites include:

• Kirkus Reviews.
• BookLikes.
• BookPage.
• Omnivoracious.
• Bookreporter.

Pros:

• You can find quality men and quality women for good, loyal, and stable partners

Cons:

• No for high achievers: reading for reading’s sake is not for highly driven people

How to Use Book Review Websites

I often read reviews before I start reading the book.

It helps me prepare my mind for the information I am about to absorb, which makes my reading and my knowledge acquisition all the more efficient.

I also read reviews after I read the book, especially so when I’m not sure I fully got the message.

On my after-the-book review reading, I look for the following:

• Criticism of the book (some imperfection I missed?)
• Opposing information (what are other theories in the field?)
• Similar books (which I might get)
• Is the book still valid (or are there new current thoughts and/or studies that disprove the book?)

What to Look For in Site Book Reviews

To make your reading efficient, you should find book review websites that give you clear and concise information.
I especially look for reviews that highlight:

• Main concepts in the books
• Main drawbacks
• Criticism (from the reviewer or from the rest of the literature)
• And finally: does the reviewer recommend the book?

That’s why for me it’s so crucial to trust the reviewer.
I need to trust the reviewer almost, and sometimes even more so, than the author of the book.

That’s why I’m not the biggest fan of Amazon reviews.

And that’s why I don’t like book reviews from big newspapers -like The New York Times-.
They all tend to be too flowery, long, and unstructured.
You finish reading the book review and you’re not even sure: did the reviewer liked the book or not. Does he recommend it or not?

I’m not looking for a literary piece.
I’m looking for information that makes my knowledge acquisition as efficient as possible.

Also, read:

• Best book summaries websites
• Best books