I was at the local museum alone, checking out an art exhibit I enjoyed...Suddenly I spot these two cute young girls next to an art piece. I tease them and make a comment on how they're in my way to break the ice. It works like a charm. We get talking, I kino both of them, their shoulders, use strong eye contact, and position their bodies from various angles to see the art pieces. We hang out for about 2 hours. They ask me for their number and I get both of theirs. We'll call them amy and sarah. I didn't know them back then, but here's what happened.

I found them both attractive and interesting, I find out they're childhood friends. I felt like amy was more interested in me but I didn't feel like we'd get along when we first met.

her other friend, sarah got my number and texted me first.

sarah is slightly more outgoing, and seems experienced with guys, and a bit of the girl you have to watch out for because she knows the game..and she'll play you if you keep your guard down, she's very aware of the things i do to an odd level..she's the "sexy" bad girl(not my type, but I didn't know it back then)..

amy is more of a quite down to earth girl you can trust, sort of nice and goody girl but she's a bit withheld sometimes..she's the cute chill type..which is definitely my type

sarah was more assertive and texted me first so i just assumed she was more interested and i hit on her and just replied to amy when she texted me.

They ask me to hang out, and we hang out 3 times. At times I could feel amy feeling bad despite giving both of them attention.

At first I keep attention on both of them, but by the second and third time it becomes clear who I like and flirt hard with sarah, not knowing she's not my type. I kino pretty hard in front of amy, and we make comments about being couples and being married.

..we were going on a date but it got scrapped due to various things. we havent been one on one or kissed.

but after meeting them three times i realized the conversations i had were ALL with amy and the whole time we were the ones enjoying our time and clicking while I was just getting sexual with sarah and not really talking. My reaction is this and i realize i felt the chemistry with amy...the whole time it was right in my face and i couldn't see it. problem is i feel like amy has sort of backed off now physically and they had some sort of agreement. she still texts me and we talk. i don't feel like sarah would be right for me..because she's a bit of a bad girl...and i'm the type of guy that would get along with amy because we share similar traits.

I want to make the switch to amy, but I feel like it's pretty cemented and I'm not sure how to go about this, despite hinting via text that I do sort of like her much earlier. I'm thinking of just doing a 180 and asking her out. I'm going to assume she's loyal and will either ask her friend or might even say no..hopefully she doesn't say anything to her friend.

tl;dr met two girls, unknowingly went for the bad girl, i find out i get along way better with the good girl but i already have been hitting on bad girl for a long time, in front of her friend good girl. i want to make the switch to the good girl. what do i do.

How do I make the switch to the girl I'm actually more compatible with?