So today a girl I met on Craigslist came to visit (I know Craigslist sucks but it's rural here. It's literally the only way I meet single women). We've been texting for a while and the conversation had turned to sex. She seemed shy but eager to meet. Sent me a topless pic so yay (sucks because I'm an ass guy/don't even like boobs).

Today she came to visit and it was... Awkward. She was shy, I couldn't think of what to do or say, and it was a mess. We watched a movie (Idiocracy), looked at a few funny cat videos and shit on YouTube, and afterwords I essentially asked her what she was interested in doing, heavily implying sex. She said, "I don't know... Anything."

I put on a John Mayer playlist on Pandora and pretty much tried to lead her to my bed then. She got super shy and pulled away from me completely. At this point things felt super awkward. Really, really awkward and I had no idea what to do. I didn't expect that reaction at all.

Thoughts folks? Where and how severely did I fuck up here? I just don't get it.

Supposedly she's going to come visit again tomorrow. We'll see if that even happens and if you guys have any advice I'll take it to heart.