So I talked to these girls at the bar and was mostly only friendly because I wasn’t particularly interested, just wanted to be social, meet new people, and I vaguely knew one of them. Anyways their friend comes later on and she’s nearly exactly my type.

I wasn’t sure what to do that night so I just chilled with them all and made some light moves on one of the girls that I don’t find super physically attractive, because she seemed to be the only available one and she was feeling me. We had talked a lot before her friend came. Not sure why I even made any light moves (just physical touch stuff) I felt some strange internal pressure I guess.

Anyways, the girl I’m interested in met a guy that night and he’s chill and we all hung out the next night, and I’m wondering if it’s too late to try and go for her instead. We ended up later watching a movie at my place and the hot girl was in his arm, the other girl in mine. Still that’s the biggest thing I’ve done and I really don’t think I wanna go any further even if she might expect it.

Is it too late to go for the other girl?

Tl;Dr:

Made friends with a girl who likes me but I’m way more interested in her best friend. I’ve already given some impression that I was pursuing the less hot girl but I wish I could revoke them. Should I just scratch the whole thing, or got for it even though that seems mean?