If you absolutely had to choose someone to marry, would you rather...

Be with a girl who has been in 5 relationships throughout her life and has only had sex with those 5 guys. But you knew for a fact that in each relationship the sex was absolutely terrible every time, completely vanilla, never lasted very long, and for shits and giggles, each guy was lacking down south.

Or

Be with a girl who has only been in one relationship her entire life and has only ever had sex with that one guy. But, you knew for a fact that this guy absolutely tore her up, and she had amazing sex uninhibited sex with him throughout their relationship. And for the sake of this question, let's assume she has legitimately completely moved on from it by the time you meet her.

This is purely rhetorical. But it's a question I sometimes find myself musing about. Because I feel like there's a justification for either answer. And whenever I lean towards one, I always stop myself and think, well maybe I'd rather have the other.

What are your guys' thoughts on this scenario?