Theory

I will cut to the point: My theory is that nobody actually ever stays in the redpill-sphere for long. The reason why Hamza and other redpillers have managed to build and maintain a growing community over the years regardless boils down to two factors.

-----

Reason 1) People who watch these videos to feel good (-> Normies)

Don’t underestimate the amount of people who watch self-improvement videos without ever self-improving. It’s akin to new year’s resolutions, the vast majority never follows through with them because it was never serious to begin with, they just wanted to ease their conscience. The average man is definitely not on self-improvement and has absolutely no interest in doing so, as that would already require basic things like stopping drug use and cutting out on junk food.

​

Reason 2) The replenishment effect.

In order to explain this, we have to agree that the biggest portion of men is bluepilled. The magnitude of the different pills is then as follows:

bluepill >> redpill > blackpill >> whitepill

What does this mean? I have always viewed this pill ideology as a natural flow of life. Every man starts out bluepilled, it’s a logical consequence of children’s innocence and the way we educate them about life. Think about the garbage mass-manufactured bluepill movies we show them as toddlers. Or the "advice" our parents gave us. The list goes on and on.

Quite some men stay in this state for their entire lives; others don’t. Now, I think it’s exceedingly rare to transition from blue- to blackpill immediately. It’s too extreme for most. The redpill is the bridge between them. People will eventually find out that their blue mindset of “everything will play out right for me simply because I exist” is utter nonsense. They seek to take their fate into their own hands.

This is exactly where the redpill comes in. It offers – at first glance – all the solutions: in order to succeed, you have to work hard. Money and women will not come from alone; however, you can earn them by putting in the effort required – and you will be rewarded.

So, if we agree that bluepill >> redpill, it is logical why Hamza, etc. can maintain their community. Nobody stays redpilled for long. I will elaborate the reason at the end. It’s not that they (the influencers) have a religious following, they have an everlasting replenishment of new viewers.

For every guy that leaves the community behind, there’s a couple new ones coming in. Bluepilled men outnumber redpilled men into the hundreds or even thousands. If we agree that bluepilled men have two options, either stay bluepilled or become redpilled, it’s only logical that there will be a considerable amount, relatively, that converts in their lifetime.Think of a slaughterhouse. Even though every single animal is butchered and shipped off,they never run out of animals. They always have an abundance in supply right off the bat.

This leaves them with a surplus of viewers: There are more joining than leaving. So yes, the redpill grows, but it's not a formidable union, it's fleeting. How is every single person supposed to become rich or get all the women? Without losers, there are no winners.

-----

Nobody stays redpilled for long

To convert to the redpill, you have to internalize the just-world mindset. The fundamental belief is that hard work will be rewarded, either with money or women (or both). There is a problem, though:We do not live in a just world. We very obviously don’t.

However, the redpill vehemently denies this fact. Its whole ideology builds upon the just-world fallacy. Viewers can only take so much of their lies until they realize the bullshit they are sold. The harder they try, the more they see the ugly truth of our unfair world. It's the redpill rage: When you have actually worked your ass off in any aspect of life and find yourself in exactly the same situation as before. No improvement, only stress and hassle you withwent.

This is obviously most prominent in the dating market. No matter what anyone says, women are the number one priority for any redpiller. And logically, the redpill attracts those kinds of men the most who have been dealt the worst hand in life, for someone who is attractive from the get-go would never have to bother with improving first.

I don’t want to stretch this too far because it’s so trivial, so I will just mention this: It is only a matter of time before you become absolutely fed up with how they treat you like a stupid child. The other day, I saw Tristan Tate give dating advice. Of course, it was all about his rizz/confidence. This man is a godly height of 6’4 with a sturdy skeletal frame. Some 5’8 framelet will not be deceived forever. Eventually, their patience and energy to continue fighting a lost battle is simply used up.

Confidence is not a character trait; it’s not learned and not built. It’s born. There are no shy chads with self-esteem issues. There are also no introverted chads (in the colloquial sense). Being shy, lacking confidence or desire to socialize is a result of being bullied and rejected, and the number one reason for bullying is looks. Only -cels get bullied, because they are ugly. No mysterious rizz to be learned.

Once the redpiller will no longer put up with this, they either transition further, to the blackpill, or simply become dormant, i.e. drown themselves in ignorance and try to detransition back to the bluepill. I cannot imagine a single person that could bear this whole nonsense for longer than maybe a year. You will experience that women do not value your hard work one way or another. You will see lazy, despicable guys get the action while you do push-ups at 5 in the morning and read two books a week. You will realize that maybe your genetic makeup is simply unfit to compete with them and self-improvement was never more than a cope to begin with.