I was out a few weeks ago and met these two girls (A) & (B). I went up to them and started conversation and it turned out well, and I grabbed both their Instagrams but I was way more interested in (B). I get a message on tinder and it turns out I matched with (A) months ago and she remembered me. I obviously try to pawn her off to a friend and she was neutral about it.

Now I'm snapchatting (A) every other day, etc. Till one day she snaps me a pic of her and (B) together so I ask her to hook me up with her and I'll hook her up with one of my friends and she's cool with it they both agree to do a double date type of situation. As the day goes on (A) is sending me butt pics, nudes, and basically building her resume up to the point where I say shit maybe I chose the wrong girl lmao. I suggest we switch and I start talking to (A) instead and she was afraid of what (B) would think because they're roommates but she did it anyway. A few days later while (B) was away on vacation I banged her and it was a very very solid fuck, gave the best head of 2016.

I regret fucking (A) because (B) is atleast 2 points hotter than (A) and now she's showing major interest as of recent.

Long story short - is it possible to finesse the situation and switch again to start fucking (B) and maybe pawn (A) off to one of my friends like originally planned.

Update 1/5/2017 - I saw (A) getting breakfast with a guy on snapchat and I realized that was my way out of this situation. So I texted her saying "I saw you were getting breakfast with bae which is cool so I'm assuming we were just a one time thing, so would it be cool with you if I start talking to and hanging out with (B)" and she ended up being cool about it saying "just don't tell her we fucked" and I'm cool with that lmao. Made it out with the prize and no burned bridges.