High SMV man (alpha behavior/leader/good looking) with little sexual experience vs. Avg SMV man with lots of sexual experience.

Who will the girl peceive as the "better fuck".

I know that girls think get alpha goggles on and see a 4 inch dick as an 8 incher, and vice versa. The hilarious guy who went beta is now fucking repulsive and she replaces him with a new Chad. Does this same "alpha goggle" concept apply to the above example?