So long story short a girl I was seeing was pretty much a match in things I think are important: Values Goals Humour Temperament Sex Significance of family

Only thing is, realistically, I'd say she is about a 5-6 and I usually date better looking women I'd say about 7-8s. I do feel if I end marrying this girl we'd have a good life.

My question is how important at the end of the day is beauty in a partner? Mind you she is not fat or super ugly but I just don't get that wow she is pretty or even cute feeling.

How important is having a combination of looks and substance or do looks even really matter at all?