So I hooked up with a girl.

We end up making out and all of our clothes come off, I then eat her out and she gives me a bj. After that I go over and get a condom that I put on. She actually helps me get the condom out of its package because my hands are too sweaty, but every time I try to put it in she says in a teasing manner "not on the first date". Throughout the next couple of minutes I keep trying for like 5 times but it is the same response every time, always in the same teasing manner. In the end I give up and just get a handjob from her.

Has anyone experienced this? Should I have done something different?