Sup dudes

I'm wondering if anyone can relate to this. I'm a really pale guy. And I mean REALLY pale. I've grown up always being the ugly dude of the group.

Recently me and some mates went on a vacation for 2 weeks, I was pretty tanned afterwards. I went out shortly after and one of my female acquaintances reached out to me to say that her friend thought I was hot. Until last month no one has ever told me I'm hot. We hooked up for a bit but I managed to screw it up (I still have much to learn, I admit).

Since then I've been going to a tanning booth weekly and I've had multiple compliments about my looks. Needless to say the difference between how I'm percieved is flabbergasting.

Now the bad part: tanning is bad. Melanoma actually runs in the family. Can anyone help me out what to do?