Whats wrong with me 29M?

4 points22 commentssubmitted by Lostmosutache to r/dating_advice

So I've been trying to get a girlfriend for years now and I'm feeling a little lost and discouraged with the whole thing. Im not sure where Im going wrong but I must be doing something wrong because with every girl I've gone out with - they've been attracted to me but then after a 2nd or 3rd date i usually get the "ill let you know.." which i guess is universal for rejection, that and a number of them continue to message me sometimes never mind they've come off not interested- i don't reply. and for some reason when I go out sometimes with these girls they either introduce me to their ex cause they're still friends or we bump into a hookup they had - this mostly may be due to living in a small town (300,000). this happens in every city with in the country i live in and part of me is starting to wonder if it's maybe the dating culture. Im not angry or bitter but I'd like some input or at least some people more experienced in this than I to weigh in

a bit about me

  • 29M
  • Luxury store manager
  • Have a degree in design
  • above average height
  • athletic build
  • never had a girlfriend before
  • no girlfriend but good amount of sex in general
  • very direct and upfront, say what I want and what I'm looking for and what i will and won't do ( gym vs doing drugs and drinking for fun)

I have 2 good friends, Im damn good socially, confident, I don't push for sex (my preference) Im unsure on how to continue dating or even get a good start since everything seems to fizzle out.

The most recent thing to happen which has sparked this post:

Went out to town and ran into a girl that I met at a friends birthday, spent the night at her house but didn't have sex, which she was happy about. went on a date and everything seemed ok, even kissed. then went to her birthday party introduced me to her mom and family/friends, all loved me, HOWEVER - She had her ex-boyfriend there cause they're still friends so shoulder shrug on that one.

Went back to her place again and slept together no sex which she stated was still happy about. then she says as im leaving to text her when i get home and we can do something same day, so i go home shower, eat and clean a bit , all taking about 1hr and some and then text- she says she hadn't moved since i left and shell head over to her parents but asked if she could text me later to see if I'm free. i just replied all good but then she still text back "I'll text you ???" so I said yea text me with a kiss emoji.

she text later around 8 and says she had a busier than expected day and asked how mine was, had a chat then I said depending on her new job's first week schedule and how intense it gets ( Officer) if she wanted to go out again- she said "could be keen/interested, I'll let you know!" I've Immediately gone no contact as a precaution.

And thats where I'm at folks, completely at a lost to what I've done wrong or what possible could have been a misstep on my part. I have a few theories:

  • I made the fatal mistake of texting back to go out because i misunderstood her plans hence coming off needy
  • I didn't try to have sex with her on her birthday night and instead we made out a ton but she said thats what she prefers for now
  • She may feel we've seen too much of each other already with our date being on Thursday , Bday on Saturday sleeping over Sunday then asking her out for later in the week ?
  • She invited the ex-boyfriend to compare and has decided the grass isn't greener and will go back to him (they broke up 5 months ago) she says she wanted to hit on me when she first saw me but they were together.
  • I did tell her I liked but she said she liked me too and kept saying things like "I work around the corner from you, i could come have lunch with you!" or " we can gym together"
  • think's I'm a loser for whatever reason?
  • thinks my job is lame
  • doesn't like me or find me attractive as much as she said and I though and was just saying that
  • She DOES genuinely like me but seriously doesn't know what her week holds due to having to work from afternoon till midnight
  • she could sense I want a girlfriend and rather still being single after the last guy even though in my opinion i made no obvious reference to matching up or labels quickly
  • She DOES genuinely like me but seriously doesn't know what her week holds due to having to work from afternoon till midnight -This whole thing is me reading too much into it and it's in my head snd i should just sit and wait before i do something dumb
  • Just one in a line of bad timing/luck with the wrong girl for me, and not to give up

TLDR; thought a girl liked me and maybe still does, very unsure due to a enthusiastic "ill let you know" all online dating advice points to dead in the water- need rescue team/advice.