You were very helpful last post, so here is an additional installment. Every week I makeout with 1-3 girls: 7's and higher. There is no issue getting their attraction, dancing, and getting numbers. This has been a mixture of sober girls, tipsy girls and ones who even initiate the interaction with me. Converting this to sex seems to be my problem.

I have had limited success getting ONS, (I did get head twice, but even those girls never replied next day) and granted this is over about a 4 month period with 50+ makeouts (so not terrible, but still not the desired results)

The pattern is always the same. They encourage me to text them and jokingly say I won't text them. I try to follow up with a text, something simple along the lines of "Hey had fun with you ln ;)" Flirty and simple. This results in me trying to set plans and them either never replying back after a few texts or not answering period.

It honestly is mindboggling that these girls are choosing me over plenty of other candidates in the bar, will make out with me, then adamantly refuse to go home with me and never reply to me again. How should I tweak my game? Should I not make out with them and see if that increases their intrigue or maybe just focus on day game?

Also this is NYC/Long Island, I have noticed girls from other states are FAR more receptive and less flaky.