I have a year until university (exactly 12 months) I'm 17 turning 18 In November and taking a 5th year in high school.

I've been lifting for a year. I'm wondering if I should bulk or cut? I'm 5'11, 190lbs at 21% body fat (so I don't have a good chin and I have a muffin top, id say Im mildly chubby) but at the same time I'm also not huge either (I have 13 inch arms)...so basically if I went on a cut I'd be in otter mode and if I bulked I'd be fat swole.

I want to look good in clothes and have girls open me based off of looks alone. If I'm lean my jaw will look more defined but I'll be "small" compared to other guys and if I bulk I'll be fat as fuck.

Which would you recommend for someone going into college? Bulk and get fatswole or cut and become ottermode? (The goal is to be the most attractive to the opposite sex)