If I'm trying to be friendly, I don't get great responses when trying to bro it up with guys, or from girls (especially from guys, strangely enough). By trying to be friendly, I mean big smile, asking lots of questions, sounding interested in what they have to stay.

But when I don't give a fuck, (ie small smile, a quick 'yo whatup bro', giving them some shit/teasing them) people are friendlier towards me.

This probably has something to do with an abundance mentality even with friends, but it's just interesting to me that the stereotypical way to making friends doesn't seem to work for me.

Thoughts?