I've been making new friends at collage, and I'm the most social I've ever been. I can approach average to great looking women without nervousness, but I don't know how to properly escalate, much less close. I want to start making more approaches since I'm starting to gain a good reputation for being a caring and deep person, but I fear of losing my good reputation early into college.

I actually have an example of a massive failure, but I'll leave it at this for now. What should I do?