I think I already know the answer to this, but just wanting to confirm..

Guy A - natural born Chad. Genetic lotto winner. Any girl he dates/fucks in his prime becomes an alpha widow for him.

Guy B - not a natural born, but keeps working hard to improve himself.

----- Years Go By ------

Guy A - Coasted on his gifts and has fallen apart into a flabby mess.

Guy B - Has improved himself to the point where he's now well beyond Guy A.

Problem: Any woman that Guy B dates/fucks now who was with Guy A back in his prime is not thinking "Guy B is now so much better than Guy A now"... instead, in her pretty little mind, she's comparing him to Guy A in his prime and still longs for that (even though Guy A in his prime no longer exists)

Correct?