~ archived since 2018 ~
~ archived since 2018 ~
| Upvotes | Comment on | Subreddit | Date (UTC) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | The Red Pill’s Virgin Shaming: How It Turns a Kernel of Evolutionary Psychology into a Toxic WeaponYou make a completely fair and sharp point, and I appreciate the critique. You are right; I conflated intrinsic human worth with dating market attractiveness, and that made the post sound like idealistic coping. Let me address the "harder question" directly without softening the harsh reality. Yes, inexperience is absolutely a negative signal in the average dating market. Lack of experience implies a lack of social proof, potential awkwardness, and the risk that the guy hasn't been "vetted" by o… | /r/ExRedPill | 13/04/26 10:42 AM |
| 5 | The Biggest Problem with the Red Pill: The Disease of GeneralizationComo eu disse, eles consideram que o que se passa nos seus círculos e nos ambientes em que participam é o próprio mundo real, a própria vida real. | /r/ExRedPill | 01/04/26 12:24 PM |
| 1 | Fallacies in Red Pill (Part I) - The Biological Determinism Fallacy (Based on Science)Thanks for your effort. So, won't the other parts be coming? | /r/ExRedPill | 03/11/25 09:38 AM |
| – | [Debate] The conflict between "Societal/RP Stoicism" and the Islamic ideal of the "Merciful & Gentle Man"You have now moved from a logical fallacy to open prejudice ('That's the reputation of muslims'). I cannot debate your personal feelings, your anecdotes, or what you perceive as a 'reputation.' I will not be drawn into a 'whataboutism' competition about which national or religious group has more criminals. It is a complete derailment from the topic. Let's focus on the only thing my post is about: The Standard. You are (rightfully) disgusted and horrified by the men who commit these crimes. Ask y… | /r/PurplePillDebate | 30/10/25 07:03 AM |
| – | [Debate] The conflict between "Societal/RP Stoicism" and the Islamic ideal of the "Merciful & Gentle Man"With respect, 'muslims are just outnumber here all of others' is a sweeping generalization based on media perception, not data. It’s a prejudiced claim, and I am not here to debate prejudice. But let's look at the core of your logic. You are passionately (and rightly) condemning these men. You are condemning them for their violence, their cruelty, and their complete lack of self-control. By doing this, you are unintentionally agreeing with the entire premise of my original post. My post argues t… | /r/PurplePillDebate | 29/10/25 06:52 PM |
| – | [Debate] The conflict between "Societal/RP Stoicism" and the Islamic ideal of the "Merciful & Gentle Man"With respect, you are moving the goalposts to an impossible standard. You've moved from "criminals exist" to "no people follow the ideal." This is a massive generalization that ignores the millions (billions?) of Muslim men who are not committing these crimes and are striving to be merciful. My ideal gives us the benchmark to condemn those criminals. Your argument is: "Until 1.8+ billion people achieve perfection, their moral ideal isn't even worth discussing." This is a double standard. As anot… | /r/PurplePillDebate | 29/10/25 06:27 PM |
| – | [Debate] The conflict between "Societal/RP Stoicism" and the Islamic ideal of the "Merciful & Gentle Man"This is the very heart of the Purple Pill debate. Thank you for framing it fairly. You're presenting the core RP premise: that female 'visceral attraction' is immutably wired to 'stone age dominance' (Dark Triad, hypergamy, etc.), and that this is the primary 'fact of nature' we must deal with. I would argue this premise confuses two different concepts: Short-Term Mating (SMP) / Arousal: What you call 'visceral turn-on.' Long-Term Mating (LMP) / Partnership Value: What is required for a stable, … | /r/PurplePillDebate | 29/10/25 05:43 PM |
| – | [Debate] The conflict between "Societal/RP Stoicism" and the Islamic ideal of the "Merciful & Gentle Man"That's a fair question. You haven't missed anything, but let's be precise about the debate. My original post is a comparison of two models or ideals: The RP/Societal Ideal (Stoic, harsh, dominant) The Islamic Ideal (Merciful, gentle, self-controlled) You're asking why I'm focusing on the "scriptural theory" and not "how it actually worked out." I'm focusing on the "theory" (the benchmark) because that's what an ideal is. If I were to compare the RP ideal (e.g., "frame," "dominance") with the wor… | /r/PurplePillDebate | 29/10/25 05:31 PM |
| – | [Debate] The conflict between "Societal/RP Stoicism" and the Islamic ideal of the "Merciful & Gentle Man"You're describing horrific crimes committed by men who fail the Islamic ideal. My post defines the ideal man as one who controls his anger, is merciful, and gentle. The criminals you listed are the exact opposite of this. You're pointing at the disease (uncontrolled male rage). My post is offering the theological cure. The existence of criminals doesn't invalidate the moral law they are breaking. It just proves why that law is necessary. | /r/PurplePillDebate | 29/10/25 05:21 PM |
| – | [Debate] The conflict between "Societal/RP Stoicism" and the Islamic ideal of the "Merciful & Gentle Man"That's a false premise. You call the Islamic ideal 'theoretical,' but it's a 1400-year-old practical code of conduct. It was 'battle-tested' by its founder (Prophet Muhammad pbuh), who wasn't an isolated monk but a statesman, general, husband, and father. The verse I quoted (Quran 3:159) is the ultimate 'battle test' review: It explicitly states his leadership succeeded in practice because he was lenient, not harsh—otherwise 'they would have disbanded from about you.' You call the societal/RP mo… | /r/PurplePillDebate | 29/10/25 05:13 PM |
| – | [Debate] The conflict between "Societal/RP Stoicism" and the Islamic ideal of the "Merciful & Gentle Man"This comment conflates theological ideals (what my post is about) with cultural practices (what you're critiquing). You suggest a Muslim man's gentleness is an 'easy' perk because the system 'subjugates' women. My theological argument is the exact opposite. The Islamic virtue of gentleness or 'controlling anger' (like in the Hadith I quoted) is not a virtue if it's 'easy.' It's a virtue precisely because one has the power (physical, social) to be harsh, but chooses self-control. True strength is… | /r/PurplePillDebate | 29/10/25 04:48 PM |
| 2 | Red Pill Detox First Aid Kit - Start Here!The link for the 'Butchering the Alpha Male' article isn't working anymore. | /r/ExRedPill | 21/10/25 11:35 AM |
© TheRedArchive 2026. All rights reserved.
created by /u/dream-hunter