I've met one "natural" (yeah the PUA's referred to him as a "natural") who claimed to have 200 hundred lays. I winged with him dozens of times. I saw him pull once. I saw him get a few numbers, and a makeout with a semi-cute, but overweight girl. The hot girl didn't want to make out with him so handed him off to a single, willing girl in her group.

I've met some successful PUA's, but most of them focus on low-hanging fruit, passable 6's or worse.