I know girls who had kinda alpha guys they broke up with and are now dating "confortable" mediocre guys. My highschool crush dated some 6'4 alpha guy for, years broke up with him and now is with another guy from my school who was not alpha at all and never had much success with girls- No college degree, average height, not going to the gym (they are both now 25 or 26y.o).

She seems happy to me but is that possible (they are only toheger for a few months)?