TLDR: im engaged to my perfect man. we met in his hometown and we moved away to an expensive big city for my college (1 year and 4 months together). i thought everything was perfect but he suddenly tells me he misses his hometown, family, friends and his potential life back home. im heartbroken as this seems to be insinuating i ruined his life and took away all sources of happiness. he says this isnt true, but i dont know. im worried the longer we stay here the more there’ll be a wedge between us, but i cant do anything about our situation now.
im engaged to a man who is absolutely perfect in my eyes. i am madly in love with him, he has no flaws to me, i am so incredibly happy with our life and our relationship in ways i could never imagine.
we met when i lived in his hometown. we lived there for a year, then moved to the city we now live in so i could be here for college. i had plans to move here for college years before i met him, and he agreed.
admittedly, he doesnt love this city. he knows no one and his family is still in his hometown. this city is very expensive. he just works and makes music. and i go to school, have friends, have a job, am familiar with the city as i lived here before, love the busyness of a big city, etc etc. hes an introvert as am i and he doesnt try to make friends and hasnt had a ton of friends in the past. but he seemed ok w his lack of friends and seemed accepting of the fact that he, for now, has to sacrifice living in a city he doesnt love to be with me.
we’re in quarantine right now. im loving him like crazy like always and i know he loves me. he is not the most verbally loving to me (but he shows it thru actions). he always has seemed a little depressed and unhappy with life since i met him. the quarantine bummed him out a bit more than usual since it just reminds him ‘its one thing after another’ with our struggle for money (two min wage jobs in an expensive city). i know its not an ideal situation and i feel guilty from time to time. all this makes him sound like hes not a strong partner, but he is all that and more and is coping greatly with his flaws and is an incredible man in every way. anyway, it all came to a head tonight when he facetimed his mom who lives in his hometown.
after the call, he said sadly, “i can tell she misses me.” and i was struck again with guilt about dragging him out here to a shitty situation that was 100% my fault. but instead of shoving in his face my own sadness, i let him talk. hes not the most emotional, so i grab onto any chance i get to hear his innermost feelings. he goes on to ask me with a sad smile, “do we really need to stay here?” i explain again, “i need to baby, for school.” and he nods. he goes on to say a long statement, basically saying he misses his family, he misses his hometown, he misses his friends (most of his old friends were female and he says he cant talk to them bc he doesnt want to hurt me as im admittedly a very jealous type), he misses not being in a financial rut living paycheck to paycheck. unrelated to me, hes been feeling a lot of regret lately of decisions hes made in the past and thinking a lot what couldve been different if he stayed in contact w certain people and took different opportunities than he did.
i let him talk and tried to comfort him the best i could, and hid my tears, but ive been really hurt since. to me, everything he was saying was that ive ruined his life and taken away everything thats made him happy. he says this isnt true, but it seems obvious. i wonder if he thinks about whether im worth it. it adds on considerably to a lot of guilt i already have about how ive conducted my life, and the mistakes ive made. i can see his side 100% and often think it was a mistake to move here, but now i cant do anything about it. i am scared its going to keep pushing a wedge between us the longer we live here. im scared and hurt.
i just felt like our fairy tale that i imagined we had is false. at least not in his eyes. i wonder if he loves me the way i love him. i wonder if he hates our life together.
[–]ange-nocturne1 point2 points3 points (0 children) | Copy Link
It sounds like he is relying on you to make the decisions for him and you also feel like this is your responsibility. However, the reality is he is a grown man who agreed to move to that city with you of his own accord. There's no need for you to feel guilty. Next time he complains about missing home, direct the conversation to what solutions he can think of. Maybe both of you can go back for a visit, maybe you can even transfer to a college closer to his hometown.
Also what is going to happen long term? After you get a degree, you will have the higher earning potential and will most likely be the breadwinner of your relationship. Is that what you want? Right now your dynamic sounds a bit like a mother and child, not very red pill. Peel back all the "fairy tale love" stuff and realistically evaluate the relationship for what it is. If you are engaged and you want a successful marriage you need to think about these things.
[–]teaandtalk30, married 8 years1 point2 points3 points (0 children) | Copy Link
As I said on the original post, you risk losing a man you describe as perfect in order to go to a community college in your preferred city. If he wants to move home, I'd say do it.
[–]_trixie_firecracker_31 - 5 years married, 7 total0 points1 point2 points (0 children) | Copy Link
What led you to SF in the first place? Trying to break into the tech industry? That place is so awfully expensive I couldn’t imagine living there as a couple unless our combined income was at least $500k/year. I’d move to Portland just to save money - and Portland ain’t cheap! Compared to San Francisco, though, the cost of living is more reasonable. If you were at UC Berkeley or Stanford, I’d tell you to stay in the Bay Area and finish your degree, but if you’re at a community college, I’d think transferring wouldn’t harm you in the long run (not trying to be elitist, just pragmatic).
[–]Longhu0 points1 point2 points (0 children) | Copy Link
Advice from another man.
First, usually men are like cientific books. That means that we are usually literal about what we are saying. If he says that you did not ruin his life, you didn't.
Second, it seems that he just wants to go back home with you. He wants to be happy and "just" having a good wife is not enough. We need many other things, like family, friends, hobbies, food and etc.
Here is the important advice: MEN AND WOMEN NEED DIFFERENT THINGS TO HAVE A GOOD LIFE AND A GOOD MARRIAGE.
Men want to be happy by having pleasure in their life.
Men have a different relationship to sensitive pleasure than women. We need it (pleasure) to survive in this world. Unhappyness is what destroy men. That's why is commonly known by all societies in all times that men suicide more than women. The thing that destroy most women is fear, not unhappyness, that's why many women can resist to unhappy situations by many, many years before doing something. This is not the case for men. Unhappyness affects us entirely and profoundly.
In your situation I would consider coming back to your home town after your college ends or making him find friends and things that makes him happy where you are. Maybe he finds happyness in your city and changes his mind? Who knows?
Note: Traditional men don't talk much about feelings. Don't push him to it. It's not good, contrary to what psychologists say nowadays. But when they talk...they're literal.