I recently got into a reddit discussion (discussion on my end, argument on the other end) with some random person and would like to know if I'm conveying these concepts in a correct manner.

http://i.imgur.com/qLPOzaT.png

I'd like for none of you to step in the conversation but rather critique my analysis. Am I on the right path? I've lurked for awhile and think i've got a solid foundation on the core beliefs of this subreddit; hell, this way of life. I still haven't turned many of my new found beliefs into actions (aka still fairly blue pill) but i'm working out to try and better myself first. Also, why is it that so many people like to rag on us with insufficient information as to who we actually are? Is it hate culture?