I've been seeing this girl for a few weeks, and we got to talking about history. I asked how many guys she'd slept with, and instead of giving a number she just launched into her life story. About the guy she lost her virginity to in college on their 1-yr anniversary, the heartbreak when they broke up. Her semester of depression when she thought she'd lost "the one", only to find love with a good guy friend who had been there for her all along (#2). The long-distance not working after graduation, and the new guy she found after that (#3) who she dated for about a year and a half until they realized their long-term goals weren't aligned re: kids etc.

I'm used to always assuming girls are lying, and multiplying anything they say by 3 or 4. But usually I just get a number, not a saga. I asked if she'd ever had a ONS, and she said no. Given that she doesn't drink, hates loud music, and I met her at a Magic: The Gathering tournament, I want to believe. On the other hand, AWALT, and she's an attractive woman in her prime.

So what gives?