I feel like I have done everything this sub recommends and I still have limited success with women.

I have a pretty good social life have lots of hobbies like rock climbing, skiing and acroyoga. I have a great job and for the most part I make friends really easily and I have a lot of female friends. In fact the last girl I dated ( a year and half ago) told me I have an abnormal number of attractive female friends. I carry myself with confidence 90% of the time but I just can't seem to carry it over to girls I'm interested in. In fact the other night I was out with some friends from a volunteer thing I do and I don't remember how it came up but we started talking about our dating lives and none of the people there believed me when I said I had nothing going on and wasn't good with girls.

I feel like the only part of my life I can't figure out is my dating and I hate it.