So I asked two girls out online for dates, with one saying she'd be down for it, even suggesting a place she likes. So I asked slyly for her number with no response a day later.

Second girl, I sent a similar messaging asking for a date like this: "Great.

So there's this smart and athletic girl that I'm taking out for an amazing first date. I can tell she's crazy about me, but I don't know whether we should go to a classy restaurant (she seems kind of sophisticated) or a relaxed tapas bar without more character (she also seems down to earth). She's good at volleyball in case that matters. Since you're a wise and and worldly individual I thought you could help..."

And got this response,

"Awww really that's awesome!!" "Test your decision making rights and act in this situation. You always have a choice in every situation, just be sure to try to make the right one most of the time" ":))" "And no one in your family or any of ur friends wants to see you waste your time with someone who doesn't really love you and get hurt" "So just be careful ok"

I don't think she knows I was indirectly talking about her. And I have no idea what to write next as I have zero clue if she's interested