I'm not a "spinning plates" type of guy. I was dealt a shitty hand when it comes to the moralistic lottery: It upsets me to have sex with multiple girls at once.

On one hand I have a wild girl. High body count, unstable emotionally, weed smoker and dishonest. But I see her regularly and the sex is pretty ok.
On the other hand, I have a girl with high values. Tried to have no sex till marriage (it didn't work). Her body count is 3. THREE including me. She's slim, sexy and caring. Drug free and honest, but I can only see her twice a week and she only does anal at the moment. Her vagina is too tight from not getting fucked for 3 years.

Help me decide, thanks.