TheRedArchive

~ archived since 2018 ~

Justin_Rosenthal Archive

View 30 posts and 96 comments by Justin_Rosenthal on TheRedPill subreddit and various other subreddits related to The Red Pill community.
Search in:
In subreddits:
More
Filter by year/month:
Upvotes Title Category Author Subreddit Date (UTC)
27

Justin_Rosenthal/r/seduction13/06/16 01:12 PM
15

Justin_Rosenthal/r/seduction02/06/16 09:03 PM
12

Justin_Rosenthal/r/seduction14/04/16 07:48 PM
11

Justin_Rosenthal/r/seduction22/05/16 08:40 PM
5

Justin_Rosenthal/r/seduction09/05/16 02:14 PM
5

Justin_Rosenthal/r/seduction22/12/15 05:10 PM
5

Justin_Rosenthal/r/seduction13/07/16 12:55 PM
4

Justin_Rosenthal/r/seduction13/04/16 12:31 AM
4

Justin_Rosenthal/r/seduction28/03/16 05:15 PM
3

Justin_Rosenthal/r/seduction22/04/16 03:48 AM
3

Justin_Rosenthal/r/seduction21/07/16 01:46 AM
3

Justin_Rosenthal/r/seduction08/08/16 03:29 AM
2

Justin_Rosenthal/r/seduction22/04/16 06:37 PM
2

Justin_Rosenthal/r/seduction13/06/16 02:53 PM
2

Justin_Rosenthal/r/seduction07/04/16 09:36 PM
2

Justin_Rosenthal/r/seduction27/05/16 09:14 PM
2

Justin_Rosenthal/r/seduction22/07/16 08:02 PM
2

Justin_Rosenthal/r/seduction29/03/16 01:15 AM
2

Justin_Rosenthal/r/seduction24/05/16 02:40 AM
1

Justin_Rosenthal/r/seduction14/02/16 05:18 AM
1

Justin_Rosenthal/r/seduction15/02/16 07:19 PM
1

Justin_Rosenthal/r/seduction03/06/16 09:41 PM
1

Justin_Rosenthal/r/seduction11/05/16 05:50 PM
1

Justin_Rosenthal/r/seduction09/02/16 04:18 AM
1

Justin_Rosenthal/r/seduction04/04/16 02:54 PM
1

Justin_Rosenthal/r/seduction19/07/16 03:48 PM
0

Justin_Rosenthal/r/seduction16/04/16 04:59 AM
0

Justin_Rosenthal/r/seduction25/04/16 12:38 AM
0

Justin_Rosenthal/r/seduction08/05/16 01:29 AM
0

Justin_Rosenthal/r/seduction13/05/16 03:57 PM
Upvotes Comment on Subreddit Date (UTC)
2

Midwesterners unite. Yea idk. His swag is mediocre, but he pushed through till he gets something to click. But honestly if I were a girl I wouldn't want his dick in me.
/r/seduction21/09/16 07:30 AM
7

I mean for him he did well for his status, but as a person I think he's just lame and has potential to be not lame
/r/seduction21/09/16 03:00 AM
86

Why the fuck is this upvoted. He sounds a millennial like me, but he's a generic fuck who says "gangster" like 10 times and "chill" like he's me when I was a nerd at the age of 17 and felt slightly cool and flamboyant
/r/seduction21/09/16 02:49 AM
1

I can respect that enough that I don't care enough to argue
/r/seduction14/09/16 08:37 AM
1

I don't want a girl that will put up with crass prodding. You can be sexual and still have class idk
/r/seduction14/09/16 06:46 AM
2

Thanks. It's off the cusp but it's from a bunch of General PUA paradigms Follow the advice and watch you profits fly high like a crow!
/r/seduction14/09/16 06:44 AM
3

Guys come on. Can we not agree this type of shit is creepy, desperate, neckbeard remarks?
/r/seduction14/09/16 03:55 AM
3

Don't take it the wrong way, but getting a girls snapchat is almost the equivalent to following her on Instagram. Girls that are iffy about a guy can easily ghost them on both. This is from a fuck ton of flaky social media accounts added on my side Secondly, it's not the specific fact you're texting so much, but that you're making her think with these quick, devolved replies that your time is better spent texting girls online you've never met. In my opinion, if you distance yourself from you wom…
/r/seduction14/09/16 03:33 AM
1

Good connection before and lost a lot of weight and she texted him first? Fish in'a barrel
/r/seduction26/08/16 02:34 PM
1

I'm just saying you need to at least observe one reaction of her to you saying whatever you want. You COULD walk up and say "damn, nice tits", then seen her reaction whether she wants you fucking dick or if she is disgusted by you BEFORE you put your hand on someone's ass. Do you want to be that dumbfuck with a misdemeanor? That's what it means to have some fucking class as a man. It doesn't matter how trashy the girls are, don't be a piece of shit to people you don't even know. Guys like you ar…
/r/seduction26/08/16 02:29 PM
1

Eye contact will be the biggest indicator, how's she's sitting with her shoulder facing you or not, how completely she's facing you like if she's like 30 degrees rotates clockwise/counter clockwise, hand placement on the table or if they're more drawn into herself and on her lap, if she's literally leaning into you at all when you laugh or create tension but whispering some shit in her ear , rather than sit upright, how much she's smiling. Don't just count the times she laughed or smiled, but wh…
/r/seduction26/08/16 02:17 PM
5

Your last third was genuinely retarded. Op do not say that when you fucking meet for the first time. You still need to present some type of personality and fucking class before you open your mouth. Glance at them when you first meet maybe to convey a sexual vibe. But pair that with being a whatever your idea of a "cool fucking dude" , and have fun and be optimistic good shit will happen, and it will.
/r/seduction26/08/16 01:38 PM
2

I think max is the most genuine out of them all. I think Madison and the French dude just suck. But I can say that there are a lot of good lessons I've learned from a lot of Tyler's videos and also Todd. Julien too, I just haven't watched too much from him. I really liked Max's video about his trouble with depression. It was a nice change from the constant "everything is perfect" feel I get from the others. That being said I can agree that although I think some of them are good guys, there's jus…
/r/seduction24/08/16 01:26 AM
2

Now I'm jealous af. Good work making an awesome genuine connection and having balls of steel
/r/seduction17/08/16 12:12 PM
2

It's fine I realize you're just trying to help me, but in a slightly annoyed way lol. It takes a lot for me to resent someone. Have a good day man, you're not a douche
/r/seduction09/08/16 05:51 PM
1

There's nothing wrong with saying hi and I'm blank. I think that talking to people daily and pushing yourself and your brain to speak and think on a deeper level is where real growth stems from because you're becoming a more interesting man. Even if you came up to a girl and starting laughing at yourself for how not ready and nervous you are approaching them shows pure genuineness and balls. But you've got to understand if you talk and act like that's all you are is a nervous man, she won't want…
/r/seduction09/08/16 05:49 PM
2

It's fine haha, I'd be no better if I let myself react to others. Have a great day dude
/r/seduction09/08/16 05:42 PM
2

I realize I come off that way trust me I'm fine in person if you met me. I sound like a noobie who reads too much material and doesn't go out enough. I appreciate it
/r/seduction09/08/16 05:42 PM
2

I realize it sounds obnoxious because it's just talking about theory but I don't waste time thinking that much about it. I appreciate the balls to call me out though lol
/r/seduction09/08/16 02:16 PM
8

Honestly I get the point of planned openers, but start being more creative and focus on freeing your mind and try to look at the scenario in a different way that's actually intriguing to someone else, but more importantly to yourself. True confidence comes from not knowing how a conversation will flow, but embracing the grounded belief that you will dig your way out of any conversation you're thrown into or any reaction the girl has. Recalling another post title I saw about vulnerability being p…
/r/seduction09/08/16 04:49 AM
1

All good
/r/seduction09/08/16 01:10 AM
1

RSD Todd and many others talk about how things you say either fluctuate the level of value or comfort a girl feels for you. Too much comfort and there's no sexual tension -> friend zoned. Too much value and she doesn't know that you won't just leave her and you're not down to earth
/r/seduction08/08/16 04:41 AM
1

I meaaaaan I'm all for jokes but like, maybe if it was the older sister's guitar it wouldn't make me think it's as wrong. But I mean the sentiment of the action was awesome and I'm glad you can feel so open with girls. Just don't slap your dick on anything an underage girl owns.
/r/seduction06/08/16 03:25 PM
1

And how old is said sister?
/r/seduction06/08/16 11:32 AM
4

I would assume he means the first one and he's not a practicing sociopath
/r/seduction30/07/16 12:06 PM
1

Maybe he's drunk even though most of them don't really drink. But yea it's just the fakeness of his persona when he's gaming and "having fun". Idk and let's be honest these types of niche jobs would definitely show an attraction for sociopaths. Maybe he's a good sociopath who knows
/r/seduction23/07/16 12:11 AM
1

I thought it was about being the bigger man, ignoring their surface reaction and then talking them through their side, empathize to a degree, then be constructive about it after they're done talking (bitching)
/r/seduction21/07/16 10:43 PM
2

Did you read the book? (not being condescendingly)
/r/seduction21/07/16 02:43 AM
1

Are you referring to your ex?
/r/seduction20/07/16 03:18 PM
1

Oh well I don't think it's going to go down well if I text a girl that I had a thing with for three months about what she did wrong haha but I might give it a shot
/r/seduction20/07/16 01:41 AM
1

Sometime*?
/r/seduction19/07/16 10:37 PM
3

Because every girl I've interacted with is a pool of information and lessons that I can learn, not only with women, but mostly for my own personal growth and knowing myself. When you get both sides of the story there's so much potential growth. I know if the generic guy asked this is you would know they just want to know the "truth" so they can feel better about themselves and re-feel any closeness as they did before.
/r/seduction19/07/16 05:02 PM
1

I agree with the soccer thing, and non PC as in Louie CK, Bill Bur humor. Just a little more edgy for most but it's usually taken well if they can grasp it. Shouldn't I say what I want to stay true to myself and not care about what people think of me? I only offend or just cant relate to 1/3 of the people/girls I meet and I have to work my way up to dark dry humor and layered jokes. I believe it's showing congruency when I say what I want. I use to apologize all the time I didn't say I do it any…
/r/seduction15/07/16 01:54 PM
0

I know how to have great conversations without it and nah I'm really funny, even if someone doesn't understand my humor, I'm going to say it because it's funny to me and I know it's funny. I realize in the beginning I should refrain a bit so I can cultivate sexual tension though
/r/seduction15/07/16 01:44 PM
1

Like when I played sports I always apologized if my passes weren't perfect and everyone saw that weakness and I could tell it annoyed them, so later on they always chastised me in a douchy sport if I messed up and I never felt good enough enough though I was starting varsity. I just have non PC humor and it if offend a girl I tried to play it and if she didn't immediately say it's ok, i would go into super apologetic, "I'm so fucking sorry i didn't mean bla blah blah, I said it because I thought…
/r/seduction14/07/16 12:41 PM
1

God damn I needed this.
/r/seduction24/06/16 03:45 AM
3

https://youtu.be/-yUafzOXHPE
/r/seduction22/06/16 04:36 PM
1

I meant to reply to someone's comment.
/r/seduction14/06/16 03:07 PM
1

Agree and amplify?
/r/seduction13/06/16 04:27 PM
1

lol no I'm not racist
/r/seduction04/06/16 09:25 PM
1

Classy
/r/seduction03/06/16 09:42 PM
1

Or they're just addicted to their phones
/r/seduction03/06/16 02:29 PM
1

I'm just referring to girls I've recently met where I'm either talking to in person or texting and they just drop it on me. It might be manipulative for me to find a way to use the situation to make her think I'm higher value than her, but I'm not out to hurt girls feelings ya know
/r/seduction27/05/16 10:03 PM
3

I feel like it's lowering your value if you prove they're wrong. And I think if you basically insult them it's not helping either
/r/seduction27/05/16 09:33 PM
1

The thing is I always have something funny to say like I literally had her crying because she was laughing so much. To be honest I think that if it was a normal girl I would've stayed in my humor comfort zone and not purposely try to cross the line just because I was desperate for a reaction
/r/seduction24/05/16 08:29 PM
1

My intent is always to make a connection with the girl and if she's hot but we just sort of get along then I'd just fuck her
/r/seduction24/05/16 07:23 PM
1

I feel like it's so deeply ingrained in me that I love making people laugh and just making them happier with nothing in return :/ Unless it's self amusement it's basically needy?
/r/seduction24/05/16 03:52 AM
2

But you're not suppose to approach from behind?!
/r/seduction23/05/16 05:15 PM
2

I like this
/r/seduction23/05/16 11:29 AM
2

I'm probably just overthinking it
/r/seduction23/05/16 01:34 AM
1

That's true. I'll stick by those words. I just remember Tyler saying you should never make the girl your purpose but then he basically contradicts himself by saying you're still on your purpose by gaming in a high volume area and gaining momentum but maybe he's right
/r/seduction23/05/16 12:47 AM
2

Just like in a RSD video when the blatantly zoom in on hot girls
/r/seduction23/05/16 12:46 AM
17

How am I suppose to a scope out the babes??
/r/seduction22/05/16 09:28 PM
3

The thing is I passed her but I wasn't sure what to do plus I just got done working out. Is it bad to only leave the house to go approach her?
/r/seduction22/05/16 09:19 PM
1

I don't know exactly what your first questions means because I'm not going to school here
/r/seduction12/05/16 04:07 AM
1

I'm on campus but school is out ...
/r/seduction12/05/16 03:45 AM
1

I know this sounds stupid but should I have one even if I really hate taking pictures of myself?
/r/seduction10/05/16 01:26 PM
1

I mean when walking around aka looking at girls asses
/r/seduction08/05/16 05:02 AM
1

Can you rephrase that?
/r/seduction08/05/16 04:07 AM
1

I know the whole "fuck texting game, approach" but there's no way I could further something between her now unless it's through text because I met her for 10 minutes and made the best of it
/r/seduction25/04/16 01:14 AM
1

Aww thanks. But yea it's so true
/r/seduction23/04/16 10:31 PM
1

1st: because I thought it would be something we could both laugh at. And she was messing up and accidentally opened it and then I joked and said put it in there. Then when she started to I said I was just joking but ok 2. Yea I really felt like I should've because she smiled surprisingly and seemed grateful that I would sit with her and maybe make her day or something 3rd: yea I know I just got a bit nervous because she wasn't very into the conversation after I made her laugh about the exam thin…
/r/seduction22/04/16 11:48 PM
1

No I know I'm not trying to just blow your advice off, I take all advice I to consideration. I'm sure straightforward would be pretty successful so I could skip the bullshit
/r/seduction22/04/16 11:44 PM
1

So transition just because it shows your manly and take charge? And thanks for the "good work", granted I talked to a bunch of people that day and boosted my state so it was way way easier and I knew I'd have the balls to approach sometime during the day. It's funny how I think I'm decent at this, but I feel like I am but there's so much work to be done. Also if a girl doesn't text me or something like that even when I think there a sliver of opportunity where it was a fault on her part, should …
/r/seduction22/04/16 02:25 PM
1

Although I feel that it can be very effective to be very direct like that and if it's the type of girl that will respond well to something like that, than do it. But from what I've read (not experienced, I know) but you through out a larger net when you don't just start with a compliment. Especially if you're not taking to people in the surrounding because you're automatically giving her more value
/r/seduction22/04/16 02:18 PM
0

Although I feel that it can be very effective to be very direct like that and if it's the type of girl that will respond well to something like that, than do it. But from what I've read (not experienced, I know) but you through out a larger net when you don't just start with a compliment. Especially if you're not taking to people in the surrounding because you're automatically giving her more value
/r/seduction22/04/16 02:18 PM
1

Ok duly noted. And yea I thought I saw her friend give her a look like "is he really asking for your number?" But yea. And the give I talked to at diner who I thought it went well with never texted me which surprised me because I thought we got along even though she was pretty quite
/r/seduction22/04/16 02:16 PM
1

also forgot the last approach. I saw a girl from my class with headphones and assumed she was sitting alone, asked if I could sit with her, we talked for like 20 minutes and I end up getting her number
/r/seduction22/04/16 03:58 AM
1

Do they usually let them go? They went together and I feel like her friend would've been really reluctant
/r/seduction16/04/16 04:33 PM
1

No I understand that. So after I basically get her friend to like me and I start to focus my attention on the girl I want, once I've created attraction and have kino'd a bit, then I try to isolate?
/r/seduction16/04/16 03:17 PM
1

Honestly I went to the concert to have fun with my friends. I had no intention of getting girls but when I got there I was like "eh fuck it. Let's see how things go" goal last night was to just approach and talk to a bunch of people to get more use to the whole scenario. Especially since I've never tried to pickup somewhere where the environment was that loud. Maybe I prefaced this wrong by calling it a FR And how am I suppose to pull a girl away from her friends? Just do it?
/r/seduction16/04/16 02:18 PM
1

Also I know it's super fucking long and disorganized also kinda awesome update. The girl on the vent texted me back after I said it was nice talking to them and first said "So am i😄😄😄😄" then an hour later and she texts me AGAIN before I replied saying "I'm actually really happy you stopped it was nice and I'm not sure you interrupted anything " holy shit that type of stuff has never happened to me.
/r/seduction16/04/16 05:14 AM
1

lol good luck being a dick the rest of your life I'm sure you'll go far
/r/seduction15/04/16 01:39 PM
1

Thank you. I've know this is what I need to do three months ago. I've just been watching so many RSD Tyler videos but I've basically only done one actually approach and I got a lot out of it, but I don't know why I've been so afraid to approach. I know I have no excuse though
/r/seduction15/04/16 05:11 AM
1

I never said I was. And for having my first kiss last semester I would say it isn't too bad. I'm a freshman too so
/r/seduction15/04/16 05:08 AM
1

Lol for one you're an asshole and two I've been with 7 girls since I was here? Doesn't mean I can't be lonely as fuck dickhead
/r/seduction15/04/16 04:50 AM
1

Damn. Well thanks for that lesson. So should I just be bold like the other guy suggested?
/r/seduction13/04/16 04:15 PM
1

She said she's definitely not down for long distance things so if it wasn't for that, I would agree with you. I do appreciate the "beta" insight because in a way I believe that. Should I still text her and try to hang out more? Or just hang out again, kino and if she calls me out be bold and state what I want and if she doesn't want the same thing than she can find someone else? Or something else
/r/seduction13/04/16 04:14 PM
1

Read the long comment above. But do you think that I should try going down the path of convincing her to breakup with him?
/r/seduction13/04/16 12:24 PM
1

But shouldn't I be trying to interact with people I come in contact with? And I only ask because I use to listen to music everywhere I went to I've basically bad years of isolation and I'm trying to break that streak
/r/seduction13/04/16 12:14 PM
1

Yea true. It's just yesterday were talking about how knowing French would "help in sexual endeavors" and she basically told be she would "promise to brush up on it". But yea I think you're totally right because she texts me like I would text a girlfriend when I'm in high school aka like reply back super quick both ways
/r/seduction13/04/16 12:13 PM
1

Ugh it's complicated. She's dating a guy that she'll break up with at the end of this semester because she found out he's going to a different college next year. So she's hinted at ending it because ya pointless but she still came to the conclusion that she's staying with him for now unless she gets the nerve to sack up and just end it. And we have really good chemistry and basically get along just as well as a great conversation with a girl would go, and not just on a friend level. Like playful…
/r/seduction13/04/16 02:39 AM
1

Thank you I'll definitely try this out
/r/seduction07/04/16 11:40 PM
1

What's the communities thoughts on David Wygant in regards to you should just say it's ok if she doesn't want to sleep with you. In regards to LMR it seems like this community tries to push its way through.
/r/seduction05/04/16 10:25 PM
1

After setting up a date should you text her every day at the very least to keep the chemistry going or can you not text them days in between?
/r/seduction05/04/16 12:55 AM
1

Trust me I know I have a self confidence issue and I know it really doesn't matter (that much) how you look. I gravitated to him because we have the same music taste and do some of the same hobbies. I know what type of friends I want but I just don't meet them because I'm not trying to reach out and start new friendships unless it's as simple as talking to someone in a class. It's just that I'm too afraid to just start talking to strangers. I have my headphones in u less I'm in class or with oth…
/r/seduction04/04/16 05:31 PM
1

1.) I meant we hung out and did stuff for three months of hanging out like at least every other day ish. I meant it more of like after a couple times hanging out with mutual friends she started flirting with me and show signs one day and then everything naturally escalated and then that night we "hung out" for about 7 hours just making out and what not. 2.) I realized I let her treat me that way so that I empower myself. I realized that I need to stop sacrificing my values just to keep hanging o…
/r/seduction04/04/16 05:23 PM
1

Should I avoid listening to music in public (headphones)? Can you use self deprecating humor if it's for self amusement?
/r/seduction04/04/16 12:16 AM
1

What are other examples of making her qualify herself?
/r/seduction29/03/16 12:43 AM
1

I'm in college
/r/seduction15/02/16 10:41 PM
1

But what if you're ordering something at a place like qdoba and she just orders after you with the assumption that you're paying for her?
/r/seduction15/02/16 07:23 PM
1

Can't you escalate during a coffee date? If not what are "good" ideas for dates
/r/seduction14/02/16 06:28 PM
1

I don't understand. Is the PUA community against like any date?
/r/seduction14/02/16 04:23 PM
1

But I feel like kissing when your breath tastes shitty is not that hot
/r/seduction14/02/16 06:08 AM
6

He seems like like he thinks he knows everything about pickup and the way he goes about it just makes me think of the generic creepy guy at the club trying to get his dick wet
/r/seduction22/12/15 08:39 PM
1

Why do you think that??
/r/seduction22/12/15 06:55 PM
You can kill a man, but you can't kill an idea.

© TheRedArchive 2026. All rights reserved.
created by /u/dream-hunter