I am a senior in high school. Most of my friends are girls. The two girls that this FR will focus on are my past prom date, a petite, beautiful 17 y/o blonde who I am friendly with but don't talk to all the time anymore. We had a good time and cuddled very intimately after prom, but people were around so we didn't hook up. She has always had a boyfriend since then and has one right now too.

The other girl I will mention is my current prom date. She is a very athletic Indian 19 y/o who I talk to every day. She skipped a year to pursue her sport which she is the national champion in. We share two classes together, workout together, have gone to movies alone together, and text almost every day. We only started talking this year, but are close friends. She has even gone back and like pictures of me on Facebook from last year with my past prom date and told me to make them my profile picture. Nothing has ever happened between us even though everyone at school thinks we might be dating.

Anyway, for my 18th birthday a group of five of my friends consisting of 4 girls and one guy (who is gay) come over to my house. I ordered a ton of Mexican and we eat, play smash bros, and chat. I show them around my place, then after dinner we all end up in my room talking. Now the girl who was my past prom date from last year hops into my bed with me. My prom date from this year joins her. As we talk, everyone eventually migrates onto my bed. We are all laying there as we gossip. We talk about everything from what we really think about our classmates at school to our first impressions of each other, to how unfair it is that I have the biggest chest despite being a guy (from working out, not man boobs I swear!). Then my past prom date begins holding my hand and we swing our arms together back and forth as she mentions losing her virginity to her abusive exboyfriend. She starts getting very touchy with me, but then one of my friends mentions it is time to go to the show.

Finally, we go out to see a comedy show. It turns out to be a small improv show with an audience of maybe 50. At the beginning of the show, the host asks if anyone wants to just have a short conversation with them in front of the audience. I raise my hand, and by some miracle they chose me. I am involved in theater at school and I sing, so I am pretty good at putting on a performance. I talked about how I play squash, I talk about how me and my friends are all artsy kids who go to a school where they demand we play sports, I talk about performing in musicals. At this point my current prom date shouts out from the crowd that I am the nationally ranked in chess. The improv troop asks me funny stories about that for a bit. Throughout the conversation, I make a bunch of jokes and get many laughs. After about 10 mins, I go back to the audience, and the improv team bases the whole 1 hour show based on what I told them. My friends loved it.

At the end of the show, my current prom date tells me I stole the show. I thank her, and we go to get gelato. Then we head back to my place. On our way back, my current prom date asks if I am gay. I joke that I am not rejecting her advances cause I am gay. She has asked me if I am gay before and knows I am 100% straight. We talk for a bit more about the show. It is about 9pm now, all of my other friends leave, and it is just me and my current prom date. She says she is hot in the kitchen, so we head to my bedroom. I sit on the bed and she sits in a chair in my room. We are alone. For the next thirty minutes we have the most boring conversation about school. At last, her phone rings and her family picks her up to go home.

I can't help thinking I missed some opportunities. Help seddit. Thanks for reading.