Backstory: Approached them both while they were together, both very pretty, one(no.1) was receptive and liking me so i escalated on her while playfully pushing away the other one(no.2), which was ignoring me and giving a lot of shittests. Anyway, i found out both of them like me. Now no.1 of the girls is in town, no.2 is not. I was texting no.2 for a while, but was not having any contact with the other one(no.1). Anyway, no.2 asked me to stay in town until she comes back, which is always a nice sign.

I was wondering how would i, and should i, go about dating them both. They are solid friends but i like to think i am big enough for both. So was wondering should i go and start up a conversation when i go out with one that is here, no.1, which is the one that was giving me a lot of attention and sexual energy. And then wait until the other gets back and go out with her and see where it goes.

The worst thing maybe is i end up with only one of them? Either no.1 wont escalate and respect that i texted her friend a while. Or she will go full on and the other will step down. The best thing would obviously be competition. But alas, that is why i am asking you. Share your advice.

Btw, i would prefer to have them both, but am not opposed to having only one as a girlfriend. I am not in town that often so it would work out nicely when i get there, i will have a girl i can warm my third leg with.

TL;DR: Both like me, one is out of town, one is here. Texted the one out of town and she wants to meet up when she gets back. Should i ask out the one in town and move it from there.