Thoughts on direct vs indirect for night game and day game?

My usual view has been that indirect is ideal during the day and direct is best at night, but I'm starting to think the opposite might be true. The conventional logic is that during the day, everyone has their guard up, so it's better to go indirect so you don't come off as weird, and at night, a lot of people are out to meet people, so it's better to be more out there.

My revised opinion is that everyone goes direct at night, so being less sold might be better. And then during the day, it literally doesn't matter, the fact you approach stands out enough.

I'm sure both indirect and direct work in both scenarios for a variety or reasons, and it's ultimately a matter of being authentic, but I'm curious if any of you have a logic behind when to go direct vs indirect.