So I've been experimenting with my personality lately and I just don't know how to solve this problem.

I use to be the alpha type, but I kept getting called an asshole/dick (by my buddies) for the jokes and games I'd play with women. You know that guy that women always say, "he's such a nice guy" in a "I want to fuck him" way? I figured I could be that guy. Well, I tried at least. Turns out that just isn't the kind of guy I am.

Now that I've tried this, I just can't wrap my head around being alpha and nice. Oddly enough, people liked me more as an "asshole" than when I consciously tried to be nice. Granted, I'm sure my friends were only calling me an asshole because they're "betas", but now that I'm in nice/beta mode myself, I would at least like to get other guys opinion about being alpha and nice.

To be clear, I'm not talking about being the average "nice guy" who's too scared to do anything. I'm talking about not putting people down to build yourself up and such. Either way, shit doesn't work.

Opinions? Perspective?