I'm at a cross road here.

On one hand, there's this whole 'PUA' school of thought. Be a badboy, don't show too much interest, keep her chasing, etc. "If you give yourself up too easily, she will go for someone else who can keep her chasing." I'm sure most of you are in this frame...after all, this is a seduction subreddit, right?

On the other hand, I want to be genuine...loving...and caring to the girl I've been dating. I don't want to be a "nice" and overly eager guy though. And I'm worried that if I don't show enough interest or attention to her, then she'll find someone who does. At the same time, the "PUA" side of me is saying "Don't give yourself up so easily to her or she'll lose interest in you." But I want my girl to know that I do DESIRE and WANT her. But how do I do this in a way that's not too eager and needy (which is stemming back from my PUA/RSD mentality).

For those of you who are jumping back-and-forth between PUA/RSD mentalities and back to genuine/relationships...any advice?