Just started getting into game and one of the things I'm currently doing is expanding my social circle by going out more to places I frequent. This has led me to create new hobbies and frequent places. I've made challenges to start opening new people however I still can't shake the feeling I'm not well-liked or respected despite no clear objective that they don't

I had a bit of an experience in high school that led to this. I've always started overthinking every time after an interaction and it's hard to go and talk to the same people again as I feel they might not be as comfortable as letting on to be or in a way, think of me the random guy.

It's mainly with people i've interacted with before. I get scared to approach them again and talk to them or even interact again.

Any idea what to think or how I can deal with this?