It seems like my dates when I don't wear cologne go better than my dates when I do wear it. Small sample size, sure, but is cologne really that cool?

I have pretty good colognes too, Creed Aventus and YSL L'Homme. And I use the classic method of spraying my wrists once, pressing my wrists against my neck, then spraying my chest once.

My colognes are like 4 years old though, at least the Creed one, so maybe it gets old or something? It smells as good as it always has, but I don't know.