This is a follow up to my post here about gaming a friend. Sorry for the wall of text, but I think it's worth reading.

HB8 is a bartender, so earlier yesterday I text her and tell her to meet me at the bar where she works when I get off work, and then we'll go somewhere from there. I show up and take a seat at the bar and there's an HB2 (is she still considered a hot babe?) a few stools down from me. She strikes up a conversation with me, and HB8 is a few minutes late, so I order a beer and we chit chat back and forth. So HB8 comes in and we hug hello, she takes a seat next to me, and I don't even mention the fact that she cancelled on me a few times (good advice from askSeddit!). She orders a beer and some mozzarella sticks while we talk about where we're going to go. Now I'm not sure if it's because I had the social proof from talking to the other girl, but HB8 starts trying to feed me some of her food and initiates light kino. Of course, I kino back, touching the small of her back when I lean in, touching her thigh a few times, stuff like that.

After a while we decide to go out to smoke a cigarette. I felt like this ended up being a step in the wrong direction because we sat across from each other outside so I wasn't able to keep up the kino like I was inside. Regardless, we're having awesome banter, I tease her when I see good openings and start disqualifying her. She gets a text and tells me that her roommate wants to come out and meet us for a drink, so I say okay. At one point, a guy sitting alone at the table next to us tried to jump in the conversation a few times, but I played it off perfectly, he even opened up the 4 questions game for me to use on HB8. I also took this opportunity to talk up the waitress that was working outside, but not too much. I gave her shit about her henna tattoo and we talked about bonzai trees. At this point, HB8 tells me that her roommate is going to meet us at another bar, so we need to go.

I go up to the bar to pay my tab and HB8 tells me that she already paid it. Sweet. She offers to drive to the next bar (I'd never been there) so we get in the car and head over. The conversation is really light hearted and we realized that we have a lot in common. I used this to my advantage by disqualifying her, saying that it never works out when you have too much in common. I'm getting a lot of IOIs from her but the logistics obviously didn't work out while we were driving, so everything became a bit stagnant. So we get to the next bar and I make what I consider a major mistake: I should have kissed her when we got there or as we walked up to the door, but I pussied out. I tell myself to man up next time. Nevertheless, as we walk in, she says sorry for cancelling on me so many times. Victory is mine! I shrug it off like no big deal.

At the next bar, we meet her roommate, an HB7 (which I realized I had met months ago but forgotten her name). We exchange "Hi, how are you?" and we all decide to play cutthroat (a game of pool where all the players are trying to knock out the other players). Now I own a pool table, so I was working them over pretty bad. I was worried that I was making the game not enjoyable for them, but it actually worked out really well because it gave them an opportunity to gang up on me to try to win - which they eventually did by cheating, but I didn't even acknowledge the cheating and told them "nice game ladies!" It's also at this point that HB7 starts talking about HB8 very protectively, and told me she's #1 dick around here, and that I have to settle for #2. I actually didn't know what to say to this without coming off like an AFC or an asshole, and I felt like this was a shit test to try to get a rise out of me and prove myself to her/them, so I shrugged it off and said she could be #1 dick when she wins a game of pool.

HB8 says she wants to sing karaoke, but HB7 absolutely does not sing, so I realize that I can capitalize on this. I tell HB7 that I'm going to sing, and if she doesn't, then she can't be #1 dick anymore; because now she's just a pussy! This really won them both over, and it leads to more teasing all around. Eventually we decide to go out to the car to smoke a bowl and I began turning the conversation sexual. The next thing I know, HB8 is saying that she's been trying to get HB7 to fuck her with a strap-on, but HB7 says she wants the real thing. Now for a moment I thought about saying "I can help you with that" or some other line, but I saw this as a shit test again and told them I'll be their pimp and we can charge admission to see the show. I've gone over this part many times in my mind, wondering if I missed my chance...

So we finish smoking and head back into the bar and decide to order food. Even though HB8 is throwing me huge IOIs, I didn't want to escalate, start making out, and then leave out HB7. Instead, I actually start teasing HB7 and disqualifying her to me, while HB8 watches. Then I did the same thing to her! I can't believe how well it worked! I even tell HB8 to do the 4 questions game for HB7. And after a while, HB7 starts giving me extended eye contact and being really playful, much more than before. But I get the vibe that I'm leaving HB8 out too much, so I reel it back in and focus on her. This proved to be a good choice, since I could tell they actually started fighting for my attention a bit, and the dynamic was much better when they teamed up against me.

The night seemed to be going well, but the girls tell me that they have to be back home because they have to wake up early, so this will have to be the last drink. Coincidentally, this is when disaster struck! While I was taking a drink, some went down the wrong pipe and I had a huge coughing fit. It was terrible, I could actually feel the attraction fading. I at least saved some face by joking about how I'm never coming back here because I almost died, which brings back the playful mood. We eventually finish our drinks and decide to close our tabs. Again, HB8 informs me that she paid for mine again. Now she insisted on it because I had helped her a lot in the past, especially with some modeling head shots a while back. I tell her that she can get this one, but I'll get the next one, and next time we'll also do something that she and HB7 can win at.

As HB7 walked to her car she said "have a good night (PUA)" with long eye contact and I said the same. So we get into HB8's car and I decide that I've waited long enough and I go in for the kiss. We make out for a bit, I break away, then she repeats that she has to get up early, so she starts driving me back to my car. And it's right now we start swapping sex stories and she starts talking about how all the previous guys she dated didn't like the fact that she slept with girls. As for me, nothing turns me on more. So even though my heart jumped into my ass when I heard that, I composed myself and told her she's just dating the wrong guys, and that I like women who are comfortable with their sexuality. Next, she's talking about how any guy she dates can't just be content with sitting back and watching her with a girl either, they'd have to participate. I couldn't help but reward her for this behavior, so I laugh and say "I love you right now!" A few minutes later, as I'm telling a story, she even says it back! Keep in mind, we were both joking.

When we arrive back where my car is parked, I kiss her again and it's on. We make out for a few minutes, I start rubbing her breasts through her top, and she repeats that she needs to get up early, but I just say "I know" and continue. I work my hand down into her pants, I start rubbing her pussy, and then I start fingering her. She says again that she needs to get up early, but she's obviously into it so I keep going. This continues for a few minutes, and the next thing I know, she's unzipping my pants and she starts blowing me. And she definitely knows what she's doing. 10 minutes later we say our good byes and head our separate ways.

I realize that, according to PUA, I probably made some "mistakes" over the course of the night. But I feel like I made some great snap decisions and my game is getting much better. I can't wait to hear some feedback from you guys.

tl;dr Ran game on a girl I've known for years, then ran game on her roommate. She tells me she's also into chicks and gives me a bj