Yes, this post is kinda long, but not actually. I think it's worth reading.. some empathy required, though.

Recently there were a couple of popular threads that discussed how women are people like us, most of them want the D, and the most important thing is that you're around them enough (provided you're hygienic and well-presented, at least.)

As an example of one of the more popular posts,

I realized that women weren't these magical creatures that only fuck guys with looks or money and anyone else was wasting their time. I just realized you have to make them laugh and feel good and be good in bed and most girls will stick around even if you're broke and ugly

And a few other comments similar to this. In some cases I challenged the statement by asking, "But does this apply to socially awkward guys? Or guys who don't offer high conventional value?" and I noticed something very troubling happened. A lot of the commenters who began with this:

"Women are people, they want the D, get out there and interact with them. It's not too hard so long as you approach and learn over time"

..essentially turned into this:

"You gotta have high value, man, even if you're just desiring average-looking women. Nobody (especially women) wants something of low quality. At least offer social proof. Or look like a bad dude who does manly things. Women are pretty darn selective."

So this kind of thing bothers me, as it has always. I can't deal with contradictions too well. I'm a black-and-white thinker and therefore one of the major problems is in learning how to think about this issue properly. I'm also very easily swayed by crappy experiences being reported here and anywhere else. Like for example the fact that I've encountered at least 10 guys here in this subreddit, in just one year's time, saying it took around 1000 approaches before they got laid once.

It's kind of, either/or, with me. I need to "pick one statement." There are just 2 choices available. It's the only way I can move forward, or backward if I so choose. There is no in-between.

The first choice: "Yeah, you're past 30 still with the V card and a bit autistic and socially inexperienced and you suck balls at most things. But you're not terrible looking at least and your height isn't a problem. The reason you haven't gotten laid is you're just staying away from every social experience possible, and not approaching women. So get out there enough times, and you'll be able to get laid. There's a good chance you might just need 100 approaches, etc. Maybe more, but don't sweat it."

Second choice: "Sorry, man, but women are highly selective. You're past 30 and operating on the level of a teenager with learning problems. You'll just look strange to women, since you're so out of touch. Women are social creatures and they make sure to keep up in life. You didn't do that. So forget about it. You don't even offer social proof, your looks are average at best, you're not tall, you're not educated, you have no stability in life at all... so yeah, you got bad genetics, forget it. Obviously you stand zero chance, don't approach and don't embarrass your worthless ass.. which you know, women don't want. If you don't have a lot of quality to offer, you don't exist to women anyway."

So those are the 2 choices. I can only pick one. Which to choose?