Context: 20 yr olds, recently new LTR asked if I would remove pictures of me and other girls from my instagram because when she shows other people they say “Oh he has a lot of pictures with other girls...” and is also worried about what her parents will say to her if they ever see my account. 4 out of the 35 posts are from fraternity events such as preference dances (semi formal) and formal dances so those are where the pictures come from.

I told her I wouldn’t remove them because I didn’t want to hurt anyone’s feelings. I want to keep them for social proof but my girlfriend is also good social proof on my instagram. I only have one picture with her there because we just recently made the LTR official.

She left my place understandably upset so I can’t help but feel I’m in the wrong. Any advice would be appreciated