I’ve been using OLD for a while, but it seems like I haven’t gone on a date in FOREVER, because now I consider dropping guys for what might be small things. I wonder if I’m just purposefully finding faults or reading too much into it.

With guy #1, his first message was “I see you live between ____ and ! I just got back from _.” this isn’t indicated anywhere on my profile, so I got nervous that he was a creepy stalker. I asked him where he found that, and he said from my Instagram. Then I remembered my Instagram is linked in my bio on the dating app, and I put the 2 closest large cities to where I live on my Instagram bio. I thought it was weird that he would lurk my Instagram profile but not follow me, and then mention something that was on my Instagram. So I just said “you’re not following me though” and he replied “I thought I’d get to know you better first ;)”. I just found that weird? So he doesn’t mind looking at my page but I need to prove to him I’m “worthy” of a follow. I also find winky faces creepy.

Then with guy #2, we’ve been chatting for 4 days now. He does take a while to respond, even when I can see he’s online (it’s Okcupid). He also hasn’t asked me out yet or even hinted at it. He’s better at conversation than most guys on OLD, which is why I haven’t blocked him yet. But I don’t know how much longer I should wait, or if I should just block him now.

Am I being too nitpicky in these situations?